Mapa mental
Optimality theory
Contenido del mapa
Optimality theory
Costs, benefits and optima
- Rate maximization (relationship between cost & benefit)
- Benefit curve
- rate of E intake will inc. linearly to start off with but will eventually reach a plateau
- initially prey will be hungry and so will eat quickly, satiation will then occur
- Prey density will initially be high, then prey will diinish
- Straight cost line
- cost is linear but there will some areas where cost outweighs benefit
- Pink area is where benefits outweigh the costs.
- organisms will have two strategies to counteract this:
- 1) Minimize cost
- 2) Maximize benefit
- Natural Selection should select for organisms utilizing the optimum
Problems with optimality theory
- 1) Assumpions are naive for real world problems
- V. simple compared to real world problems, reduces fit to model
- Likely never to be perfect
- 2) assumption that evolution produces "perfect" organisms - GOULD & LEWONTIN (1979)
- We expect evo to produce efficient orgs not perfect,should not be surprised if orgs differ from model
- Models predict mathematically perfect organisms.
- 3) Animals are dumb and do not carry out complex maths
- Animals usually use rule of thumb
- 4) foraging is not the only thing that animals do
- Models are very simplistic and only include few parameters
- Didnt include predation pressure etc.
- 1) Assumpions are naive for real world problems
Optimality theory in evolutionary biology
- Competition for resources should only select for efficiency
- or it should eliminate the least efficient
- "optimality is the expected result of natural selection, for ever more efficient organisms"
- How does optimality and fitness interlink
- optimality models usually assume the maximization of indirect measures of fitness
- e.g. energy intake rate, number of mates, etc.
- optimality models usually assume the maximization of indirect measures of fitness
- Competition for resources should only select for efficiency
Maximizing energy gain over time
- Charnovs Marginal Value Theorum (1976)
- Patch Residence time
- We assume there must be some from of diminishing return (pink line)
- Short residence time (red)
- energy intake is low
- long residence time (blue)
- energy intake is much higher BUT Energy returns will eventually deplete
- What is the highest energy intake (optimum)?
- The point in which we have the steepest slope (black line), where it meets the tangent of the B V C line
- Travel time
- Long travel time
- long travel time we expect a long PRT
- Short travel time short PRT but modest energy intake
- Optimum is given by point meets tangent of original BvC line
- Long travel time
- Patch Residence time
- Charnovs Marginal Value Theorum (1976)
Optimality models
- Economics of Prey choice
- Crab feeding on mussels of varying size - ELNER & HUGHES (1988)
- Crabs did not choose prey randomly
- Crabs did not go for the largest mussels (largest benefit)
- Crabs went for intermediate sized mussels
- WHY?
- Look at costs v benefits
- time spent foraging for mussels inc. dramatically with size
- measure intake rate/time, we see a curve optimum at intermediate size
- WHY?
- Models predict most of what happens in wild but not to the exact.
- Model works widely within nature
- e.g. Grizzly bears feeding on salmon, whole salmon or on parts
- Choose to maximise protein and energy intake
- e.g. Grizzly bears feeding on salmon, whole salmon or on parts
- Crab feeding on mussels of varying size - ELNER & HUGHES (1988)
- Patch residence time
- The problem
- How long does an organism stay in one patch before choosing to leave and forage elsewhere
- e.g. turtles grazing on an algae patch
- Assumptions
- 1) there is a relationship in some way between fitness and fitness measures
- and that energy intake is important
- 2) Travel time
- Amount of time or energy to move from one place to another
- Will dictate whether an animal wll move
- 3) food depletion
- as food is eaten value of food declines
- will come a point when it benefits the animal to move
- 1) there is a relationship in some way between fitness and fitness measures
- Solutions
- Could choose extremes
- i.e. eat one mouthful and then move
- eat until patch is empty
- intermediate strategies
- these decided by several factors
- Travel time
- Food Depletion
- these decided by several factors
- Could choose extremes
- The problem
- Economics of Prey choice
Imágenes y archivos del mapa
Información
- Descripción
- (MBIO317 - Behavioural Ecology ) Marine Biology Mapa Mental sobre Optimality theory, creado por Connor Joesbury el 18/05/2019.
- Creado por
- Connor Joesbury
- Visitas
- 0
- Valoración