Flashcards
zoology

Cards in this deck (186)
- 1Computational Evolutionary BiologyDr Mary J. O'Connell
- 2Interested in patterns we obseve in genomes, processes that brought about these patterns and how these things interact with how organisms fucntionWe will look at the processes, patterns and their fucntion within animals
- 3If we want to read more about her research group, go to www.mol-evol.orgblank
- 4History - where evolutionary biology began. Darwins letter to thomas huxley in 1857The time will come i believe though i shall not live to see it, when we shall have fairly true genealogical (phlogenetic) trees of each great kingdom of nature
- 55 great kingdoms of natureanimals, fungi, plants, prokaryotes, protists
- 6The issue with darwins statementwhen it comes to prokaryotes there probably is no phylogenetic tree. There is so much horizontal gene trasnfer between species of bacteria it brings about the question 'what is a species of bacteria'. We think of prokaryotes in the sense of a web instead of a tree.
- 72 main ways in which you can evolve1. linear - going through generations (parents offspring, passing on mutations.
2. yeast or bacteria can pass on genes horizontally - 8Most of what she will talk about will be in the linear model. Central concept: Homology and mutationrichard own came up with the first idea of homology. He was director of natonal hisotry museum in london a long time ago. He was first person to come up with the idea of a homologue. He notices he could group samples of animals into major groups dependent on whether they had certain characteristics e.g backbones are vertebrates
- 9owens definition of homology (1843)homologue: the same organ under every variety of form and fucntion (true or essential correspondence).
Analogy: Superficial or misleading simularity e.g. bat wings and bird wings. Both evolved wings independently in two seperate lineages BUT their most recent common ancentor was a tetrapod whch had 4 limbs and in both cases the top two limbs became wings, so they are analogues but they can also be called deep homologoues even though their immediate ancestors didnt have wings.
Another good analogy is butterfly wings and batwings, these dont share a common ancestor, they have idependently evolved - 10Charles Darwin had his own definitionsThe natural system is based upon decent with modification.. the characters that naturalists consider as showing true affinity (i.e. homologies) are those which have been inherited from a common parent, and, in so far as all true classification is genealogical; that community of descent is the common bond that naturalists have been seeking.
- 11homology:is the simulaity that is the result f inheritance from a common ancestor - the identification and analysis of homologies is central to phylogenetic systematics
- 12True homologues from different mammalian speciesLeft human, dog, bird, whale
- 13Can also have homologues at the molecular level: genes and sequences that are shared because individuals have a common ancestore.g we have a fatty acid synthase gene the same as a dog and whale
- 14Paper: Molecules as documents of evolutionary history. Man called Linus pauling and emile zuckerkandl. Linus discovered molecular bond.Quote from paper: ''we may ask the question where in the now living systems, the greatest amount of information of their past history has survived and how it can be extracted''...''best fit are the different types of macromolecules (sequences) which carry the genetic information. Zuckerkandl and pauling 1965. They are proposing that for the first time every single thing living on the planet has witten in its genome, all of its history over time.
- 15This was the dawning of the field of molecular evolution: Alignment.Cant align any old sequence, they have to be homologues. Can identify homologues in morphology, in sequence data and once you have identified homologues in sequence data, can then align this sequence with homologues of other species. Alignment is a little bit more than this a specific position within the alignment, can say that a specific position in the alignment is inherited from a common ancestor. When you have an alignment over a number of species there are amazing things you can do with this.
- 16The way she was taught ' individuals are either homologous or they arent' this didnt sit well in her brain. What happens when there is a gene duplication event?Can result in being 50% homologous to one and 50% homologus to another. A new gene can belong in more than one gene family. Read the paper ' A pluristic account of homology: adapting the models to the data' by haggerty et al 2014.
- 17Why draw a phylogenetic tree1. Find out how species are related to one another.
2. can use the trees to undertsand disease outbreak and spread.
3. understand how genes in a gene family are related to one another.
We are going to talk about using tress to undertsand how animals are related to one another. - 18Phylogenetic reconstruction is difficult because1. No universal molecular clock exists - The idea that there is agradual and correlatory relationship between the number of mutations and the amount of time.
2. Long branch attraction
3. Saturation of sites
4. Shared base or amino acid composition biases
5. mixture of orthologues and paralogs - 19No universal molecular clock exists. Zuckerkandle and pauling proposed in 1962 that there was a molecular clock. They notes that rates of amino acid replacements in animals haemoglobins were roughly proportional to time - as judged against the fossil recordAt the time next gen sequencing and pcr didnt exist, was really difficult to get the amino acid seqence of a bunch of proteins but they managed to do it for animal haemoglobins (got it for cow, platypus, carp, chicken and shark). They also know from fossil record when each of these species diverged. Cow evolved 90 million years ago, platypus 120 million years ago, chicken 275mya, carp 380mya and carp 440 million years ago. Took alpha haemoglobin gene from these species and made an alignment. they counted for cow how many amino acid substitutions (changes) in each species. Cow had 20, platypus had 40, chicken had 48 etc. Then notices that they could draw a line of best fit which connect the dots. This made them think there was a molecular clock, there is a clock of how often mutations occur over time. Unfortunatley, it is the only protein for which this works. Realised there was no molecular clock. All proteins evolve at such different rates.
- 20Histone H4 10 to power of 9 years there is 0.01 substitions happening. However in fibrinopeptides in 10 to power of 9 years, 8.3 substitions occur, so basically different proteins evolve at different rates.This is why there is no universal molecular clock, this makes it difficult to model evolution.
Within a single protein e.g small subunit ribosomal rna, parts can evolve really fast and other might evolve very slowly. - 21There is no molecular clock:Summary: The initial proposal saw the clock as a poisson process with a constant rate. It is now known to be more complex. Differences in rates occur for different sites in a molecule, different genes, different regons of genomes(mitochondrial genenome evolves faster than nuclear), different genomes in the same cell, different taxonomic groups for the same gene (mice evolve much quicker than us)
- 22Unequal rates in different lineages may cause problems for phyogenetic analysis - different species and genes evolving at diffferent rates, might find that species that evolve more rapidly get grouped together on a phylogenetic tree when actually they arent related (this is called long branch chain attraction)Felsenstein 1978 made a simple model phylogeny inclusing four taxa and a mixture of short and long branches.
Need to use methods that allow sites or species to evolve at different rates. Methods which do not assume that all sites change at the same rate are better at recovering the true tree. - 23example of true and wrong tree

- 243. Saturation in sequence data :Saturation is due to multiple changes at the same site subsequent to lineage splitting. Might observe an M in a sequence in one species and M in another species. Possible that both M's were inherted from the same common ancestor that also was an M, or it could be that at this snapshot in time, happen to be an M, or one of them has been an M for a long time and other has only just become an M. Sometimes changes are hidden in sequence data because we only see what is present now, a snapshot in time. However now fossilised data shows what occured back in time so we can make comparisons between now and then.
Most data will contain some fast evolving sites which are potentially saturated (e.g. in proteins often position 3)
In severe cases the data becomes essentially random and all information about relatonships can be lost - 25Multiple changes at a single site which we cant observe

- 264. composition biasesDo sequences manifest biased base compositions (e.g thermophillic convergence) or biased codon usage patterns which may obscure phylogenetic signal.
Case study: deinococcus and thermus. D is raditation resistant and thermus are thermophillic bactera (heat loving). they both have same very unusual cell wall based upon the protein ornithine, both have same menaquinones, both have same unusual polar lipids.
The congruence (agreement) between these complec characters supports phylogenetic relationship between deinococcus and thermus. Because of multiple lines of evience we known they should each be each others closest relative, but trees tell us otherwise. It isnt that tree is right and biochemistry is wrong, its that the models we use may not capture the prcocess and pattern seen in the data. - 27Thermophiles have a very high GC content, mesophiles (deinococcus radiodurans) is really low. Big difference in the amount of G and Cs found in the DNA and as a result of this, end up getting thermus with aquifex cos they have high GD content and end up with bacillus with deinococcus because they have a low GC content

- 28The correct tree can be obtained if a model is used which allows base amino acid composiiton to vary between sequences - LogDet/Paralinear distances

- 29Might draw a phylogenetic tree to see how genes relate to one another - the evolutionary history between a family and species is very different. Can assume a gene tree will be the same as a species tree would be wrong. these match each other (back of slide) but this isnt always the way

- 30Just because something is homologous doesnt mean it is analgous. There are two types of homologue - orthologues and paralogues.Orthologue - gene inherited from commen acentor through speciation event alone
paralogue - genes inherited from common ancestor through gene duplication and speciation.
read about ortholgues and paralogues because slide is confusing. - 31Lecture 2Mary
- 32Going to look at how a number of genes and hope that this history shows how species evolved and not just the genes.We have just realised that giraffs are not a single species. They are a group of sub species. There is a lot that we dont know.
Read paper Phylogenomics and speciation morgan et al 2013. Mol bio and evolution - 33In the past the single ribosomal RNA was using to map species and used to draw phylogenetic trees - this is incorrectThis gene can actually be transfred horizontally as well as vertically. Researchers decided we need new methods to assess data and tried to find relationships across a number of data.
- 34Todays lecture is about resolving the root of the placental mammal phylogenyGoing to be looking at marys work alongside Dr. Claire Morgan and Ray morgan
- 35Mammal phylogeny - the debate. There were 4 competing hypothesis of how mammals were related and all 4 had support but they all differ from one another. In A, the Afrotheria are the deepest diverging mammal, tree B says it was the armadilos (family Xenarthra), tree C says it was the most recent common ancestor of the Xenarthra and Afrotheria, finally D says it is rodents.

- 36Why do we have so much conflict?Can have genes evolve at different rates, parts of genes evolve at different rates, different species evolve at different rates etc. Mammals have different body weights and sizes and this hugely affects how long it takes to evolve. Mammals have an enormous range in longevty (how long they can live for), huge difference in metabolic rates, all have different times of sexual maturity e.g mice reach sexual maturity at 3 months and reproduce, in 1 year a mice can have 3 generations, it takes 1 human 18 times longer to produce offspring, this has a big imapct on how rapidly you can put mutations into the next generation. Takes us about 16-18 years to get our mutations into next generation. Organisms that have fast metabolism have a lot of free radicles and these cause damage to DNA, so these have more mutations. Larger body size animals live for longer in general.
- 37Why have the majority of studies looking into the placental mammal root come about in the 2000sThis is when it become possible to start sequencing data and people were collecting dung samples from local zoos.
- 38Rodents early hypothesis - why might this unusual position have come out?More mutations in these species because they evolve more rapidly, not because they are older. The rodents have been placed at the base of the tree because they have so many mutations. This is an example of a long branch attraction problem.
- 39Claire and mary etc wanted to find out if all studies were using different data sets and looking at different genes, or were they using the same sets of genes and just appling different methods or why were they getting all different trees?Claire discovered for the most part the data that was used for mammal phylogeny tended to be data sets that were nested within each other e.g murphy went to trouble of collecting sequences for a variety of mammals for a small number of genes and this became the reffered to data set. Then another researcher would come along with sample from another 2 taxa and they would then sequence the same set of genes, so overtime the same data set was used over and over again with just additions of extra data. Sometimes they decided they woudnt just add a new taxa but they would add more genes for the whole cohort. Take home message from slide - different people performing analyses and different years, different number of taxa used and different genes being used, different data sizes, the one that stands out is that they have all used the exact same method of modelling. The model that they those doesnt fit all the taxa e.g. one data set had 66 mammals but the model only fit 13 out of the mammals.
- 40Models - To try and understand how models cant fit the data imagine you need to guess whether a coin will be heads or tails. 50% predict head and 50% predict tails. We have model in heads that tells us it will be 50/50, but if it was a double sided coin with both sides showing heads, then our model doesnt fit and we will not be able to predict the outcome, those that predict tails will always be wrong.These models used on data in other words were no better than random
- 41With nucleotide data it is more complicated than having a 2 sided coin, have an A, T, G or C base. These are the different states the character can be in. These can mutate to one or the other. How often we expect an A to mutate to a G is represented in a matrix, it is reversible model. However this model doesnt state how many A, T, G or C were present wihtin the data in the first place. Need to know how one nucleotide is substituted for another, how many of each were there in the first place and wether all sites are evolving at the same rate in our genes or whether they are evolving at different ratesPrevious methods assume they are all the same.
Different models
JC = all nucleotide substitutions are equally likely and all nucleotides are present in equal frequency. Very poor model.
HKY= says you can have any value for any number of A, T, G and C but some of the values for the rate substitions are the same. States it is equally likely to mutate from an A to a G or a G to a C as it is from a T to a C or C to a T but totally different likelihood to observe muation from an A to a C or a G to a T or T to an A. Purine to purine are more common than purine to pyrimidine, pyrimidine to pyrimidine is more common than pyrimidine to purine. - 42Different species evolve at different rates - having this information will help to build a better model.Developed these heterogenous models that take into account base rate variation and species rate variation (morgan et al computation (2015).
- 43Different modelsComposition vector: number of A. G, T and C. Mary is saying that there needs to be another compositon vector in the data set, why is this? because mammals have biased gene conversion whihc means that when mammals have a mutation, they are more likely to convert it to a G or a C than an A or a T. This influences those species that evolve more rapidly are also going to have more G and Cs. In the end it took claire a year to analayse data and she realised the model that she needed to use to analyse data was a model that had 3 different rate matrices(ways in which mutations can mutate), 5 different compositon vectors. This can be shown as 3GTR+5C+I+4(upside down backwards L)
- 44The model that was used and reflected data accurately wasPosterior predictive simultions 66ATaxonSet_nuc
- 45The only hypothesis the data could reject was that the rodents model was incorrect. In order to establish which model was correct they needed their own data set.Claire has 39 taxa and 20,400 amino acids aligned. She found best model of fit which had 1 JTT and 5 composition vectors, she also did it at next level above amino acids where you sub chatacterise amino acids into dayhoff categories. Dayoff categories are ways of getting 20 amino acids into 6 categories based on whether they are tiny and charged or large and non charged etc. Although they couldnt perfectly model the data, they were so much closer at modeling the data than anyone before. She found that the position for the earliest diverging root wad the Atlantogenata position.
- 46There is congruence across different data types that all state the position for the earliest placental mammal root is the atlantogenataThis meant that when combining this info with what we know tectonic plates were moving at the time it raised interesting situations for organisms like sloths. Paper raised that the ancestral lineage of sloths probably rafted across the new forming atlantic to colonise s. america.
- 47Application of phylogeny doesnt just show how species are related but also has big importance in understanding outbreak of disease.Ebola outbreak study used phylogeny to understand source and spread
- 48In summary there are many factors that make phylogeny reconstruction difficultLong branch attraction.
There are challenges and otential solutions using heterogenous modeling of the evolutionary processes. The challenge being time and fact we now have models that are going to create challenges in way we use computing. Solutions being models that do describe how organisms evolve.
Should always do critical assessment of data, does it fit to agree with or reject other data?
Application to resolving difficult nodes e.g mammal root. Still dont know about lots of different nodes e.g. 15 nodes within the metazoan groupa nd we have no idea where these animals belong, it is very difficuly to get samples. - 49Lecture 3 - Molecular AdaptationWhat makes a species unique at the molecular level?
Read the paper functional consequence of positive selection revealev through rational mutagenesis of human myeloperoxidase. Loughran et al 2012 - 50Some mutations accumulate over time and can be beneficical. Some mutations affect functioning of proteins. Darwin observed finches beak morphology, darwin proposed ancestorol finch had undergone adaptive muatation event. Some developed unusual shaped beak allowing them to eat food the others couldntblank
- 51Protein sequenceOnly a proporton of genome encodes for proteins. Can compare genomes of animals to see how we can cluster animals together and how they differ The genetic code is degenerate (multiple codons that can code an amino acid). When studying the genome and how species are related, need to compare codons as well as amino acids.
- 52Classify position of codon based on whether they change the amino acid or not.If it doesnt change the amino acid its a silent substitution/synonymous substitution - can be called Ks or Ds.
codon that changes the amino acid is called a replacement or non synonymous substitution (Ka or Dn).
Neautral: non advantageous random genetic drift occuring= Ka/Ks or Dn/Ds=1
Purifying: pressure to retain current genotype = Ka/Ks or Dn/Ds<1
Positive: pressure for change of genotype to improve fitness = Ka/Ks or Dn/Ds>1 - 53Darwins finches - beaks have very different morphology. Positive adaptation in the calmodulin pathway (imporant for different beaks).Other studies did broad anaylses of other genes as well as calmodulin pathway - they found number of different genes important in the different beaks.
- 54What di you need to consider when measuring protein evolutionDifferent proteins and regions evolve at different rates. The Dn/Ds will be different depending on which protein it is. will also depend on where abouts in the protein it is.
- 55We use site specific models - allows proteins to evolve at different rates.M0: one ratio = all parts of protein is evolving at the same rate, very unlikely.
- 56Some species evolve more rapidly than other e.g miceKnow the Dn/Ds ratio should change across phylogeny. Potein SEMG2 is a protein in primates, if a mutation occurs it can afect functioning. Its involved in binding of sperm to the egg. Mutation = no longer bind to egg of some species butcan bind to others. Also involved in how fast sperm swim. In species where there is multi male multi female systems e.g chimps this protein evolves rapidly. In non multi male multi female e.g humans (only have 1 or 2 male partners for each ovulation) have much slower rate of mutation. This is as a result of sperm competition. Fastest sperm wins, so becase of competition, this protein is under positive selection for faster swimming sperm. Behaviour can have big impact on how fast proteins evolve.
- 57Positive selection and protein fucntion. Dr. Noeleen. There is evidence that states positive selection on the genotype and the effect it has on the fucntion on the protein (phenotype).It is ossible to predict fucntional change using only sequences. MHPs involved in defence system. Has a unique feature (haemperoxidase), its involved in making hypochloris acid that burns away cell walls and cell membranes of prokaryotes, pus from wound is this acid. So it has two jobs - produces acid and is a peroxidase. All other peroxidases only do 1 job. Studies found if all three residues were present, could do both jobs but if the protein was missing any of the amino acid residues it wouldnt be able to do both. These three residues are positively selected.
- 58Large scale comparative genomics - used info gained from residues to apply to other bigger genomicsin 2014 published 79 polar bear genomes and 9 brown bear genomes. Sequenced two reference genome standards for both. Had 2 questions - when did polar bears diverge? They are endangered and their niche is melting. They are having to migrate further south and coming into contact with brown bear. On land the brown bear wins fight, polar bears win in water. Brown bear has big thick skull. Discoevered that polar bears havent been around for that long only been around for about 450,000 years. Polar bears evolved from ancestor brown bears - messy split from ancestory lineage.
- 59Polar bears have postive slection in number of genes involves in cholesterol, coat colour etc. They have 100% fat diet which they have adapted to. Coat colour genes help them adapt to their environment.They are now mating with brown bears and these are viable species.
- 60Bowhead Whales live for up to 200 years - how can species live for so long and not suffer from things like cancer. Wanted to find out what genes have been mutated allow them to live for so long.Mutations have been found in the genes on DNA damage repair and DNA cell cycle.
- 61Can use these aproaches for medical benefit. Can decide which species to test drugs on before testing on humans.Have been drug trials gone through all the testing on mice etc. They did trials on maqaques but they are still a different species and have a different ecosystem. ^ men taken ill after taking drug due to multiple organ failure.
- 62Important to understand which animals can be used as modelsWhich genes fucntion in simualr ways to humans
- 63sensory perception - tasteAll vertbrates have same way of tasting - all inherited set of genes involved in tasting. Sweet (T1R2/T1R3, bitter = T2Rs, umami/amino acid = T1R1 and T1R3. Discoeverd that birds are missing T1R2, the ancestor lost T1R2 receptor so no modern day bird should be able to taste sweet. But the humming bird can taste sweet. Huming birds have taken the umami receptor and have adapted it.
- 64William hobbitsocial learning and culture
- 65Show understanding and how can we test for the questions. Can get good mark for saying yes or no, it about how we support answer with evidence.Might ask how do we test for imitation, how do we detect culture, how do we test for teaching. Tailor knowledge to answer specific question.
- 66Social learning - defined in broad way. Demonstrator - doing action and being observed. Observer imitates the demonstrator. We need more specific term than social learning, what is thisSocial transmission(slides). e.g bird learns to sing song, bird sings, bird B observed and then sings the same song. Or might not occur through observation but instead by exposure e.g. blue tits peck through milk bottle to get to cream, this spread throughout the country. Blue tits were learning by exposure to products. One blue tit would learn to do it, then leave the milk bottle for another which would then learn to poe through bottle top next time. This isnt through observation, its by exposure. Social trasmisson can also be via verbal or written.
- 67imitation used in two sensesBroad sense (economists): the way in which one individual copies another
Narrow sense (psychologists): one individual observes and learns the motor programme for them to perform this action themself - 68Culture definition InnovationLecture slides
- 69core methodologyFall on a continuum, some methods fall under high control and reliability because we can control it, other end of continuum is validity (animals performing learning in natural habitat - natural behaviour e.g bottle nose dolphin in australia, learn that if they chase fish, they might swim into gastropod shell, they can take shell to surface and shake it until fish falls out and they can then eat it).
- 70Transmission chain: more realistic than traditional. Open diffusions : even more realistic Field experiemnts: controlled experiments in field provide high validity and highcontrolUsually a trade off between control and validity
- 71TraditonalObservation phase e.g press rat to press leaver. Put demonstrator in next cage. See if those exposed will perform task quicker compared to control.
This can be modified with multipledemonstrators or multiple observers e.g guppies observed different numbers of demonstrators swimming though green or red hole to get to food in other side of tank. When there was 1 demonstrator there wasnt much difference in which hole they swam through, when there was many demonstrators, guppies mostly followed the majority.
Can also test whether observers copy indivduals with high prestige over those with low prestige - 72Linear transmission e.g bee B learns from A, and then Bee C can learn from bee B.Example: predator recognition in black birds (curio 1988). Black bird mobbing is passed on, learn by black birds to recognise predators.
- 73Replacement transmission chain - have a number of individuals, train them to eat a certain food and then replace them one at a time and see if the behaviour remains after replacing all individuals.Rats example: 2 replacmeent trasnmission chains.
1. 4 rats trained to eat diet with pepper
2. rats trained to eat cinamon
Each day individual is replaced - 74Open diffusion experimentsGo to group in wild - let them interact in way they usually would. Present them with foraging task that may be resolved in two different ways and see how behaviour spreads through group. Sometimes may train one individual first (seeded diffusion).
Study on chimps whiten et al 2005. Pan pipe experiment solved in two ways. Poke stick through hole to access food or use stick to lift block and feed. They trained on individual in one population to use one technique and trained another indivudla from another popualtion the other technique. Majority of population follows the seeded trait. Came back two months later and found same group level method existed. - 75general scientific process1. Define process that you want to observe
2. Once defined process, what pattern would be expected
3. Recognise plausible alternative explanation
4. Might think some alternatives fit definition of limitation so may need to redefine what you mean by limitation
5. collect data capable of distinguishing target
6. Assess whether target proceess is operating
7. In order to do this might need to develop and apply specialised data analysis techniques - 76Red box Imitation definiton on slidesCorrespondence problem: need to observe motor pattern, need to translate into motor programme for me to perform it, this is a difficult thing to do.
- 77What pattern are we lookign for? Do animals have a capacity for imitation, if we are just interested in if they have capacity we want to take as much control as we can as it is difficult to observe in wild.Set up experiment: train demonstrator, expose observer to it, use control group where observer watches control cage with a lever in it. Find that almost all the observers with a demonstrator learn how to press lever and those that didnt have demonstrator dont learn. On the face ot it, it looks like obervers has learnt behaviour. Turns out this is poorly designed, could be expalined by different factors e.g social facilitation (slides) e.g rat alone may just sit in corner of cage due to lack of stimulation by other rat, stimulus enhancement (slides) e.g attention is attracted to lever because the deomstrator presses lever, so when exposed to levers i new cage it is more curious and goes to press it, its not because it has learnt to get food from it, local enhancement (slides) e.g observer is attracted to location rather than lever, observational conditioning (slides) e.g observer sees lever and food in close proximity, might make connection with lever and food, response faciliation e.g if observer sees demonstarator perfoming movement, it might go round cage performing action nd press
- 78A lot of people say imitation has to involve novelty. This is problem because in some ways every action is novel. At same time no action is truly novel, actions are composed of movements of things we have done in the past.How do we deal with problem of novelty?
Contextual imitation : animal learns to perform action in novel context
Production imitaion: have to learn novel sequence - 79Contextual imitation (slides)Production imitation (slides) could be that observer is observing exact sequence of actions making them copy exactly what they do - this is unlikely here
- 80EmulationCan be seen as type of imitation. Defintion on slides. e.g if demonstrator goes to push lever with paws, observer might go and push down lever with nose
- 81Lecture 2Task to design better experiment -want to use traditional lab method to determine whether species has capacity for type of learning. Have a lot of control and reliability in this method. Not interested in how often or if they do it in their natrual environment.
- 82Social facilitation - mere presence of demonstrator affects observers behaviourSimple to control for - control observers placed next to cage with control demonstrator in it. This doesnt rule out stimulus enhancement, local enhancement, observational conditioning. This is not sufficicent to tell us we have contextual imitation going on. Need to refine methods.
- 83Have 2 groups of observers instead of 1. One group see demonstrator move lever to the left, other group see demonstrator push lever to the right. This rules out stimulus enhancement, local enhancement and observational conditioning. Doesnt rule out emulation. Observers might just be seeing movement of lever moving to left so that group try to recreate movement of object to get food.How can we rule out emulation?
Use of ghost control. Spontaneous movement of lever which releases food - see if animals still try and recreate action or do they only recreate if individual moves lever.
Another way to rule out emulation is to train one group to push lever down with paw and train other group to push lever down with nose. Here they are not trying to recreate moevment of lever because it moves in the same way. Simular experiemnts done on qualis and chickens (atkins and zental 1996). Those that observed pecking on treddle would peck and those taught to step would step. This rules out everything - or does it???? - 84Byrne 1994 - said it might be as a result of response facilitation. e.g under this the observer sees the action of demonstrator using nose to push things, the observer might then go around a push things with nose, this could be seen as a type of imitation but they arent learning where to use actions.There is a way round this. Need to show observers use these actions in context specific way. Obervers watch one demonstrator push with nose next to red light and watches another demonstrator push with paw next to green light. This hasnt been done in rats but has been done in chickens. Also hasnt been done many times in literature.
- 85Do animals have culture? and how do we detect culture?Definition of culture is contentious, some people say culture requires teaching and imitation, others suggest culture requires human specific traits e.g language, the broad defintion which will prefers. We should ask what are the essnetial properties of culture e.g socially transmitted info or behaviour and culture results in group typical behavioural patterns. Defintion on slides.
- 86Next stage we need to identify pattern consistent with process e.g are behavioural patterns of one group different to another group? Also need to recognise plausible alternative explanations.Solid case study: chimpanzee culture (whiten et al 1999) 6 different populations in africa. Each icon is a particular behaviour performed by individuals in that group. In some places for example they may crack nuts with rocks. In different popualtions, different inovations evolved and spread through group by social transmission.
What are possible explanations? Could be difference in culture, could be genetic differenses that predispose individuals to learn differently, could be that ecological differences occur e.g indivduals that encounter simular local ecology can come up with simular techniques. - 87Collect data distinguishing culture. On the continuum for this we want a high degree of validity, we want to find out if culture really exists in natural environment.Run translocation experiment, has been done on couple species of fish. Found in different environments these french grunts had typical behaviour (migration routes and mating sites). Can rule out genetics by moving fish from one pop to another. If fish takes up behaviour from different pop then ca rule out genetic differences, they learn from everyone around them. This doesnt rule out ecological hypothesis. To rule this out need to take entire pop and translocate, so take entire pop A and translocate to pop B, if fish take up behaviour of B, it suggests ecology is a factor affecting behaviour. If they perform different bahviour to previous group B then it suggests fish come up with their own culture. This experiment is very difficult to do in bigger animals e.g chimps or whales, cant just move them around
- 88Another method for bigger animals - could open diffusion or social diffusion - main method used to do this is called the method of exclusion - highly contraversial.2 diferent versions
Basic method - flawed and results not reliable
Advanced: good way of determing behaviour is cultural - 89Basic methodAssumes there are no genetic differenced and that thee are no ecological differences, so it muct be social transmission. This is flawed method because it treats null hypothesis as if they are true. However studies have shown that genetic dissimularity is correlated with behaviour. Whiten et al showed there were cases where behaviour couldnt be performed due to lack of presence of e.g a type of food, but in areas where they did have the resource, many also didnt perform the behaviour, suggesting it is a part of some groups culture. Sometimes in some areas, chimps may have better resource which prevents them using the other resource like other populations. Difficult to rule out basic method of exclusion.
- 90AdvancedAssumes that genetic and ecological could account for behaiour we see. In this method the null hypotheis is that there is no social transmission - this is the right way roud unlike basic. Kruetzen et al 2005, dolphin uses sponge to protect itself when it goes fishing around in substrate, it was thought daughters learnt behaviour from mothers. Went through and listed all possible modes of inheritance and listed why the inheritance doesnt fit with the pattern observed, so can reject different genetic methods. However not always possible to do this and very difficult to do with ecology. Instead can use a model fitting aproach - get some measure of genetic simularity among individuals and ecological simulairty, get social simulairty and find out to what extent these things correlate with one another e.g if indivudals that hang out a lot perform the same behaviour then social transmission is likely.
- 91example of this : bower birds Madden et al 2004Variation in bower birds decoration of bowers. Could be this is due to culture, genetic or ecological. Went and got measure of genetic, ecological and behavioural dissimularities. They found no correlation between ecology and behaviour, then found that genetic dissimulairty did allow for an affect but soical dissimulairy had much more impact on behaviour.
Ecological factors always difficult to rule out completely because we never know if we are missing something. - 92Repertoire based methodsflawed - going out to take snapshot of how animals are behaving. A better way of measuring these things is using diffusion data (measure how behaviour spreads through a population and use data on the order of the spread to find out whether they are learning from one another.
- 93Lecture 3.Animal social learning and culture
- 94Diffusion data : taken over time that gives times or order in which individuals aquire behaviourDiffusion curve analaysis: plot over time the proportion of inviduals that are performing behaviour. If we have just asocial learning then we will get an r shaped curve (increase in number of individuals learning and over time it plateus). However if there is social learning we would expect S shaped curve - at first learning is slow, but as number of individuals perfoming behaviour increases, behaviour is learnt more quickly. This method as a whole has been pretty much discredited. if its a complex task with multiple steps we can still get aan s shaped diffusion curve even if there is only asocial learning going on. Basically we shouldnt use this method.
- 95More promising technique: network based diffusion analysisCase study: humpback whales. Lobtail feeding: humpback brings tail out of water and smacks it on water (lobtail is social signal). Bubble netting: is a feeding strategy bubbles create net of bubbles, all come up through bubbles to feed on prey. Lobtail feeding is when they put a lobtail sequence before their normal feeding regime. This behaviour spread through populations across couple of decades. With this model we expect the behaviour to spread depending on how much time individuals spend with each other.
- 96How can we analyse data using this logic - 2 ways1. order of aquisition diffusion analaysis
Use maximum likelihood estimation: involves translatinglogic we see into stats model. Model is that the rate of learning = S x connection to informed individual +1.
Use this model to create liklihood fucntion which tells us what the probability of the observed order for given value of s. Equation asks 'what value of s maximises the likelihood? - 97Chimps use leaf sponges to gain water from tree holes. One tree seemed to have particulairy lot of minerals. At this tree new behaviours evolves. 1. chimps reused leaves used by other chimps 2. chimps scraped moss off tree to use as sponge instead. Water hole was observed constantly. (Hobalter et al 2014.Spread of moss use follows network dependent on how much time individuals spend with one another. For this model can take into acount which individuals observed which other individuals. The spread was shown to follow observations very closely.
Fit various different models to the data. (slides) they had different weights of transmission. Social transmission was by far the most likely.
For leaf reuse 8% learnt from social but 54% from asocial learning
Moss use 85% learnt from social learning
One individual learnt independedntly (but wasnt really independent, she found leaf already used by tree and it had moss in it, and from this she started using moss). - 98Translocation experiments (french grunts) is a solid way of showing social behaviour. Chimps -Group typical behavour shown by whiten et al. They certainly have capacity for learning (shown by whiten et al), also from whiten et al pan pipes, controlled diffusion experiemnts show social behaviour spread. For high validity can use Network method.So do animals have culture?
We have strng evidence that chimps have culture, moderate evidence for things like whales and dolphins but dont have evidence they are capable of things like imitation because cant get them into lab. - 99Now we ask : do any non human animals teach other and how do we test the teaching?Various ways can teach.
Cognitive: understanding of different states of knowledge, this is difficult to show in non humans.
Better method to take is a fucntional perspective: class of behaviour patterns that are adaptations for transmitting knowledge and skills to others. So this is the definition, now need identify the process (behaviour promting learning in others), need to recognise plausible alternatives (inadvetnt social learning). - 100Rule out inadvertant social learningCaro and Hauser's (1992) operational defintiion (slides).
- 101Strong case of teaching : meerkats live in society where there are helper meerkats which help to raise pups. Helpers help pups to understand how to kill scorpians. First helper brings back scorpion back dead, then brings back scorpion with sting removed, then brings back full scorpion, to help pups learn how to kill them overtime. Tutor modifies behaviour.Helpers are sensitive to age of pupils. Helpers respond to the calls of the pups. Sound of young pup they bring back dead scorpion, old pup, they bring back alive pup. They are responding to call, its not they understand that they are young or old.
- 102Time to monitor pup goes down as pup ages. They spend more time monitoring pup when they provide live prey - this incurs cost. As pup age goes up they as less likely to lose prey and more liekly to lose it if its intact compared to whether it is disabled.These things arent for the helpers benefit because they come at cost to helper, so they must be doing these things to help pups learn.
- 103What about pupil learning skill or knowledge?Ran field experiment.
Slides
Pups dealt with stingless scorpions had 6/6 success at killing scorpion.
This is strong case of teahcing in non human animals. - 104More examples : tandem running in antsAnts lead ants to food souce, if the follower is lost the tutor goes back to find them. There is a cost because it takes them 4x longer to get to food. Tutor clearly modifies behaviour as it maintains contact with follower ant. Pupil aquires knowledge because there is an alternative way to get ant to food source by picking up ants (by this method ants dont learn). Someone critiqued this saying that this isnt teaching, its just telling others where the food source is. The distinction between being told and teaching is a difficult distinction to make.
- 105Pied babbler present call when theyve brought food back to nest. Allows young to know when food is present.Tutor modifies behaviour because they only use it around young, unless it is being used in recruiting context. There is no obvious benefit to call, also is energetically costly and could reduce feeding time.
Does pupil aquire skill or knowledge - to test this additional calls were played and showed that those subjected to more calls learnt much more effectively. - 106Marianne Lecture 1Linking environmental variation, life history responses and population dynamics
- 107Different species have different life history strategies, but differences in life history strategies also vary within single species. e.g european perch adults are different sizes. Common side bloched lizard - different colour morphs which enable them to access reproduction in different ways. What causes this variation and what consequences does it have?Differences arive from genetic variation, responses to environment and interaction between genetics and ecology.
This is important to how populations change over time and how popualtion will respond to climate change. - 108Strong relationship between life history and population dynamics. yellow bellied marmot - after 2000 population numbers rapidly increasingOzgul et al 2010. after 2000 larger adult survived better than before and smaller juvenilles were able to grow faster after 2000. Realised this explained increase in population numbers. Realised this shift was altered due to climate change causing vegetation to grow earlier, so marmots were able to come out of hibernation earlier.
We call this eco-evolutionary dynamics - 109Eco-evolutionary dynamics:history, body growth, reproduction and survival.
How do all factors interact to affect life history strategies and how this affects dynamics.
There are feedback loops in systems like this - 110Density dependence of life history and consequences for popualtion dynamics. Density dependence is when life history traits are affected by density (pop growth rate).Roe deer: Negative density dependence e.g as density increaes, fawn weight decreases.
Flour beetle: Allee effects(positive density dependence). Female reproduction rates strongly increases with density. At low density not enough males for female to mate with. As population density increases to certain point reproduction declines again because there is competition for food which affects reproduction. - 111Negative density dependence. Mechanismscompetition: exploitative or interference (only a few have access to resource and they molopolise it).
This is an important mechanism of regulating popualtion growth. Past a certain carrying capacity the growth of pop will slow down as environemnt cant support all animals. - 112Evidence in Guanaco population from chileonce population reach equilibrium no more individuals can be sustained by environment.
- 113Allee effects: 2 types Component and demographic.Within demographic there is both strong and week alle effects. Strong = there is a threshold meaning that population isnt growing, there are more individuals dying than are being born. The weak allee effect is where just about more individuals are being born than those dying, so popualtion is growing but very slowly. Population can still potentially recover
- 114Allee effects important in terms of extinction and invasions. There are many mechanisms that can leave to allee effects:mate limitation (female doesnt have access to enough males to reproduce
Cooperative defence
Cooperative feeding (not enough individuals in pack to feed)
cooperative breeding (not enough indivudals to tend to young)
Predator satiation
Dispersal (more indivduals leaving than stayng.) - 115Evidence : african wild dogsFor component allee effects there are lots of examplesAfrican wild dogs populations declining. Realised this was due to allee effect - not enough cooperative breeding.
ew examples for femographic allee effects: Vancouver island marmot: at low population size, there is negative growth rate. - 116Difficult to estimate demographic consequences of density dependence because it requires long term monitoring, need to characterise the density dependence of several life history traits and it is difficult to determine the shape and strength of density dependence in natural populations.blank
- 117small populations (endangered)Allee effects are really important. Often assumed there is no negative dependency dependence because populations are already small so there shoudlnt be competition. BUT intraspecific competition can occur in small populations and effects their ecological dynamics.
Usful to do experiments where you manipulate pop density and see the effects. - 118Case study : common lizardslides
plasticity: south europe: gro fast and produce young but die young.
Norway they do the opposite.
Both males and females have multiple partners - 119macrocosm - experimental designoutdoor enclosures, very little manipulation, natural food and basking sites, only manipulate number of individuals.
Different morphs left for same time.
For body growth, for jeuvinilles body growth decreased with increased density - affect was more on females
For juvenille females at low density almost 80% able to reproduce, at high density less than 10% able to reproduce
Clutch size - all affected in same way, as density increased, clutch size decreased.
Found in juvenille there was a slow increase in survival with increase in density, this wasnt found in adults, this is allelee afect - 120can use these traits to try and predict exptinction: can do this by builging population models e.g age structured population modelsimportant to take into account that males matter when performing these models, usually these models only take into account the females
- 121demographic allee effectmales are increasing risk of extinction. look at conclusions slide.
Look at lecture slides on invasive species - 122Lecture 2marianna
- 123Transgenerational effectForm of phenotypic variation. Most common studied is maternal effects : condition of mothers affects phenotype of the offspring.
But it isnt only mothers, paternal effects can also alter offspring life history traits.
Doesnt just affect direct descendednt, it can affect multiple generations - 1242 types of transgenerational effect1. environmental:
exposure to hormones can be transmitted in eggs by mother
exposure to immune factors such as antibodies e.g in humans through breast feeding
allocation of nutritional resources (variation in amount of nutrient in egg/food provided by mother)
exposure to behaviour and culture which are ransmitted from one generation to next e.g singing in birds - 125environmental transgenetational affectFeral pigeons - transfer of antibodies. Pigeons good to study because parents can affect phenotype in 2 ways, one being prenatal antibodies and the other being postnatal antibodies (in crop milk) produced by both parents. experiment wanted to know if there was a difference in transfer of antibodies before and after birds.
Found for prenatal: in case where biological parents were exposed to immunochallenges there was a decrease in the immune response of the chicks but only when they were exposed to the antigen at 14 days of age.
For postnatal (chicks raised by foster parents) they found opposite effect so individuals that were exposed to the immune challenge as very young chicks at 3 days old, there was an increase in the immune response to this antigen but no difference when exposed at 14 days of age.
This is an example of context dependent environmental parental effects, read paper - 1262nd mechanism of transgenic affect - epigenetic inheritanceAlterations of phenotype are altered by changing of expression of the genes.
Chromatin remodelling
- DNA methylation
- Histone modification
Non-coding RNA mediated modifications
Epigegentic alterations change all the time. To be transmitted to next generation they have to survive in the gametes and secondly they have to survive a major event of chromatin remodelling. During mieosis there is complete remodelling of chromatin. example e.g marine sticklebacks in response to ocean warming.
were interested in epigenetic inheitance could buffer populations against change in environment. Looked at 3 generation of fish, exposed to increase in temp, looked at how it affected respiratory capacity and looked at gene expression to see if it was involved. - 127They found:Mothers exposed to warmer temps had offpsring with higher and more efficient respiratory capacity - linked this to genes involves in metabolism. Also found that grand maternal environment also affected respiratory capacity. When grandmother were exposed to higher temps (21 degrees) there was metablic compensation in offspring but only if mothers were acclimated at 17 degrees. This led to differential gene expression in genes involved with homeostasis and apoptosis.
Strongest influence was maternal environment then grandmaternal environment and then offspring environment - 128Transgenerational effect of parental age e.g older mother more likely to have children with downsyndrome.Parental age can give rise to transgenerational effects through environment and genetics
- 129Transgenetional effects can have ecological implicationsTransgeneration effects can have big imapcts on population dynamics by generating a phenotypic change between individuals in a popualtion.
These effects can also have strong evolutionary implications, they can decouple phenotypic change and genetic change. Non-genetically transmitted phenotypes can affect the persistence of popualtions and adaptation to a rapid environmental change - 130Maternal effect on egg size can really affect population dynamics. Prime aged males produce bigger eggs.blank, Im lost and bored cba to make notes
- 131NavigationLecture 1
- 132Navigation needed to:find feeding ground, food, territory and mate. To navigate animals must recognice where their own position is and know where this is in relatio to their goal.
- 133Amazing navigators: Manx shearwater (puffinus puffinus). Geolocator put on legs, measures positions for 12 birds. Can use to make out xy coordinates where they are on the globe. Guilford et al , 2009All on little island, spend summer there, in autum they fly down to argentina, spring they return to rio de la plata. Navigates year after year back to the same place.
- 134How do animals achieve this?Multiple mechanisms
Different sensory mechanisms
variety of levels of sophistocation - 135Levels of sophisticationslides
random - browning in motion
chemical - sensing chemicals in water and air or any sort of gradient e.g light or magnetic field
Neurophysiological - highest level where there is a representation of the space e.g humans know where cooker is in relation to microwave. - 136Random searchusually only for short periods
- no sensory system (rare, even bacteria can sense gradients)
- no other information availible (also rate) - 137Biased searchlevy flight
- collection of a lot of brownian motion movements.
- could be a collection of random movements ( which may be a good strategy if there is no other information), followed by long movements between searches.
This is a common search pattern throughout the animal kingdom, very cheap to compute.
If this technique is used for foraging, clusters might not be random search it might be where there is a lot of food source, if food source is distributed in levy like way.
Levy flight usually used as foraging technique, limited information from sensory systems and rarely other navigation information.
See slide for image of levy distribution - frequency of path length is path lengths are divided eqally in time - longer ones (long tail) used less frequently in time. Dont need many sensory systems at all or knowldege to perform this - 138Next level up from this is a systematic search, the cataglyphis fortis ant does this a lotDuring the animals displacement, animals have been displaced by a very small amount. Ant goes round and round in ever increasing circles to try and found path it was on or the home its trying to get to. Its not random, there is a pattern to it and all of these ants do something very simular.
- 139Limitations of searchOK for finding sparse food, especially if food is distributed randomly (brownian motion) or in a levy way. Poor for finding a fixed point e.g home.
However not all sensory mechanisms are used in isolation, they can be used in conjunction with other mechanisms. - 140Often in advanced navigation they will use advanced search but as they get closer to food source they will conduct random search e.g shark to eat as many fish as possible.blank
- 141HomingMost studied element of navigation. Important for animals to find their way home to safe place away from predators, familular food source, mates and offspring. Also easier to study as had concrete predictions.
With homing studies there is a fixed point so now where to find the animal so can take animal out of home and watch how it gets back - 142Trail followingSimplest form
Trail left on way out, mating or foraging will occur out of home. This route (chemical trail) will be followed on return journey. This is usually a chmical cue. Most gastropods do this, snails leave slime trails for homing to a consistent rest spot as do other gastropods like limpets.
Chiton gastropod - whilst on foraging group, scientist rubs out trail. The gastropod goes in completely random direction and eventually finds its trail home again.
Trail thats put out will start to degrade at particular rate. - 143Termites classic example of trail followingThey use a pheremone to indciate path out from nest, follow this back to return, their trails are really straight. All following termites follow initial cue. This means you can trick them, can draw out trail with pheremone and they follow it exaclty (can use a glycogenic compound simular to their pheremone.
- 144Trail following also found in slime mouldsBecoming popular experimental organism. Collection of single cellular organisms that behave together. Can go out on foraging trips from base and go back to same route. They dont have central nervous system, done through cell sensory nervous system.
- 145Limitations of trail followingFairly infelxible, if parts are disrupted then another strategy is needed and it is an inefficient route back home. If youve gone out on a tortorous route then you need to take that route back.
- 146Route based orientationUse landmarks, remeber a series of objects, reverse this order on the way back. Simular to trail following but animal doeesnt lay down the trail, the animal just remembers the trail.
Golden hamsters do this : they are active at dawn and dusk. Hamster travels from nesting site in burrow to a foraging site. Under red light the hamsters used the objects encounterd on their way out of the nest on their return. Under visable light they returned in a straight line to the nest (animal can use two different mechanisms, can remember the objects). Golden hamster makes beeline straight back to nest. - 147Route based orientation: sensory systems1. vision
2. touch
3. mechanosensory (sensing fluid flow) - 148Limitations of route based orientationCan be inefficient, if objects move the route is unreliable, again this is inflexible.
- 149Path integrationIt is an internally based navigation system, it is also known as dead reckoning, first proposed by Darwin (1873). (see slides).
What is required for path integration?
- direction of travel
- how far has been travelled
Most famous animal to do this is the desert ant (catyglyphis fortis) - 150DirectionAnts use sky light to inform them of roataions, sky is effectively an infinite distance away, traslational movements result in no change, rotational movements can be recorded
- 151Distance - how do animals measure distance?Count steps -
to test whether ants were counting steps (shorten or lengthen legs). From results t shows ants are counting steps, animals with stumps, animals on homeward bound dont get quite as far and stilted ants have overshot the next, the normal legs got to nest exactly.
Optic flow (measuring amount of movement on the retina of the animal) this happens to humans as well, if youre in a car going fast, then movement is much faster. This measure is used by ants and bees. - 152LimitationsProne to error - odometer has to be very accurate but errors can occur
Will only get you home, not to another place you have not been to but would like to go
severely disrupted by displacement - 153Other sensory systems which can help with ant navigationlandmarks
wind direction
polarised light (ant has polarized filters on eyes)
optic flow - 154Cataglyphis uses optic flowHas two forms (worker ant and forger ant) forager carries worker to another nest where it is needed. If carrier ant is seperated from forager, it searched around where it was released (to try and find carrier ant) but next searrch was round where its origional nest was. It has no odometer information but it uses optic flow. Can tell this because in another experiment the same, the ant was blindfolded, in this experiment it performed random search but didnt find it back to nest site.
- 155View based matchingCan see a blury scene (low resolution) and compare two views with one another, they can look at how closely their two views correspond. They might take some rotations in order to get a view that corresponds to what they remember. We can show that ants use this for navigation. On a return journey to nest, put a black curtain in front of nest, can manipulate this by moving the black curtain, when the curtain is moved too far and their view no longer matches the view they remember so they use different form of navigation to return to nest.
- 156Lecture 2True navigation: means naviation go a point where you dont have a current sensory experience of, get to a point where you cant see, smell, hear.
- 157True navigationNavigation to a point out of sensory range, map and compass are required for this. Need knowledge of geographical range and knowledge of bearing of goal.
It is tested by displacement experiments, move animal to unfamiliar area and look at whether it returns home? The result will inform us of their mechanism for navigation. - 158Example : song birds from norway, navigating to southern spain. They are displaced halfway through trip. Their bearing after release indicated navigation type.Two hypotheses:
1. vector navigation - all they know is that they continue in one direction
2. true navigation - recognise they have made displacement and they adjust bearing accordingly
Can test these either with real displacmenets or simulate displacment in the lab. - 159Mechanisms - how do they shift their bearing?They need two things
1. location (map)
2. direction (compass)
This forms the map and compass hypothesis.
There are three examples of maps; magnatic map, olfactory map and cognitive map.
Two types of compass; sun compass, magnatic compass - 160Sun compassposition of sun in the sky at a certain time gives you direction
Time compensated compass
Only works in the day.
How does it work? bee uses sun compass to navigate from hive to flowers. Experiment: clock shift experiment - put bee hive in artifical environment, manipulate life cycle by shifting lighting patterns. Look at slides. (if shift clock back they bee reverts to the flower it fed at at 6pm). - 161Pigeon example - can clock shift pigeonsslides
- 162Its a bit more complex than just angle, it needs time compensation, the sun doesnt increase in angle equally throughout time, the angle between horizon and sun increases by smaller increments as it gets closer to mid day and larger increments into the evening. Also chnages with the time of year.blank
- 163Star compass : used at nightBirds Indigo buntings show normal orientation in a planetarium. If birds arent exposed to night sky when they are young then they cant use stars for navigation, they need expose when young. Once they have learnt this, birds can use individual constellations
How is this tested? Use technology where bird is in a funnel, has blotting paper around the edge and an ink well in the middle which it is stood on. Using a migratory restless bird (really wants to migrate). They measure the amount of ink that appears on the paper. Look at slides for photo of blotting paper. Some birds can use the moon as well, some use combination of moon and stars. - 164Magnetic compasscan put pigeon in a helmholtz coil, the funnel used before can be put inside this coil and birds foot blotting can be observed.
There are several components of earths magentic compass
1. horizontal components - use this with regular compass
2. vertical component - we rarely use. not used in standard compass
3. Inclination angle - this gives the horizontal and vertical component
Animals can seperat out the horizontal component, many animals can use the inclination angle on its own, rarely use vertical component. - 165Wiltschko and wiltschko, 1972 - these people devoted their lives to work on this magentic compassThey put a robin in the funnel inside the helmontz coil, manipulate agnetic field and inclination. If the polairty is reversed then they will reverse the direction they travel in. But if the inclination is put at 0, they go in a random direction. they cant just be using polairty, they are using some component of the inclination they they are using. Inclination is angle between earths surafce and magnetic field.
- 166polaity reversed - bird goes in opposite direction If polarity and inclination are reversed - bird go off in the regular direction.Birds definitely have an inclination compass, doesnt distinguish between north and south it only distinguishes equatorwards or polwards. Not many birds navigate through the equator however.
Turtles use inclination and intesity
Salmon use both inclination and polairty
mole rats just use polairty
Newts also use both types - 167How are they detecting this magnetic fieldElasmobranchs use their electroreceptors - only branch that has a lot of these specific types of receptors
Salmonids probably use biogenic magnetite? was widely accepted but recently been questioned
European robins use magnetic vision and is highly lateralised, only used in one eye that can see the magentic field. - 168MagnetoreceptionThe way they see it is through the formation of a radical pair. Radical pairs are ubiquitous, short lived, reaction intermediaries whose chemistry is controlled by a large extent by the electron and nuclear spins. We need candidate molecule that can form a radical pair - cryptochrome molecule is capable of forming a radical pair but also simular types of molecules have been found. How does it work? It has two states; singular and triplet state. A ratio is formed between the two states and this interacts with a molecule in the retina of the bird called a flav and it gives a visual representation of magnetic field.
Look at slides read paper Zapka et al 2009 - 169MapsUse two types of directional information to create a bi-coordinate grid.
Experiments to see if animals do use maps - turtle hatchlings with swim suit on and antennae attached to them to track them. Can release them into regular migratory route and see what they are able to do. Can replicate the magnetic field that is encountered at these various points in the world in the lab. A lot of tutle hatching is in the caribbean, their migration follows the flow of gulf stream and back. they actively swim through this but mainly just follow the flow. Put turtle on leash in water in the helmintz coil. - 170Olfactory mapBirds have good sense of smell, they can use their smell to navigate their way home. Huge debate about the relative importance of olfaction against magnetic. They are both important, animals can use both sensory mechanisms. Experiment does with pigeons - 3 types of lofts. Hypothesis was that birds could smell their way back to their loft. Can use things e.g forest, lake, town which all have specific smells and animals can use these smells to guide way home. The experimenter used 3 lofts, 1 was control. All lofts in same field with barriers around them that change the direction of odours coming into the loft. Birds left in there for number of weeks, learnt odours coming from the specific directions of their loft. Control birds flew back in the right direction of odours they had been exposed to. In other lofts where odours had been roatated clockwise they flew in the opposing direction - so they can defo use this as compass, but can they use it as a map?
- 171Concentrations of hydrocarbons in environment (produced everywhere) could provide map like information due to specific concs of particular hydrocarbons in different areas. May be that there are gradients of hydrocarbons in different directions creating an odour map.blank
- 172Visual landmarksCan see the goal. Animals can use a number of mechanisms.
Classic mechanism is pilotage (have particular points, travel from point to point). This is not true navigation. Often used in final stages of homing. It is simular to path integration. Can measure this using lightweight gps tracking device. Biro et al, 2004. - 173Magnetic disruptionput strong rare earth magnet on beak, which disrupts its magnetic sense. During these sorts of experiments they just relied on visual information and ignored the magnetic field.
- 174Lecture 33D navigation
- 175So far weve been talking about animals in 2 dimensional environment. This isnt the case for many other aniamls. Ants dont use much 3D info, pigeons move fully through 3D space (they leave the surface) but in order to navigate they probs only use 2D ques (bicoordinate system) not tricoodinate. Key point : how the animal moves really affects how they will encode the sapce.blank
- 176Fundamentally animals move in two different waysThree degrees of freedom of movement : ant and rats for example. This animal is constained to surface, can move fowards, backwards, left and right. It has one degreeof rotation (we call it yaw).
Soemthing like a fish however has six degrees of freedom. Has the three same as rat but has additional translational degree of freedom (move up and down/orthogonal vertical axis) and also has 2 additional rotational degree of freedom (called roll and pitch). - 177There is a complexity difference in these 2 systems. Think of ants random walk trying to find nest, it likely didnt get home and probably died (this is only in 2D), if added another dimension to that theres no way it would get home. Technically in 2D the ant would eventually get home in 2D but this is probably too long of a time for the ant to survive.How do animals deal with added complexity? Has bee a real mystery but almost certainly a piece of bicoded information (can combine horizontal with vertical)
- 178RatsPlace cells: in brain that fire when the animal is in a particular place. Very little is known about why or when they fire. Recent studies show animals anticipate animals being in a participate being in a certain position and their place cell will fire before it reaches position.
Experiment - place cell fires at one 2D position in this helix. Grid cells fire at regular intervals, they are firing at same locations as rat moves all the way up the helix. Place cells are isotropic (smaler in 2D sense than 3D sense so they are egg shaped, potentially have more info coming from horizontal than they do vertical. Grid cells only capable of coding in horizontal (no vertical coding). - 179Behavioural dataGenerally the rats prefer making horizontal movements instead of vertical. This is almost certainly because there is an energy cnstraint. They try and use less energy option first.
In a 3D lattice on a peg board they preferred horizontal movements. - 180Bats - simular size and closely related but they can fly so have 6 degrees of freedom for movement.Neorophysiological recordings taken from freely moving bats, recordings taken from place cells while they flew. key point - the field where volume fires has same resolution in horizontal as it does in the vertical, here it is equal. Currenlty no behavioural data though for bats.
- 181Fish - small, have good long memory, can navigate in 3D, live in a complex environment. Can use many ques. Experiment to find out how fish learn their 3D spaceSlide - fish placed in start box, can either swim through 2 arms. Reward one of the ends of arms to train it to swim in a particular way. Worked on blind mexican cave fish. Tried putting these animals in the start box but they always swam down. Instead used the same species fish (surface morph of same species). They learn quickly. First part of experiment: see if they could learn vertical informaton, trained fish to swim vertically or horizontally. Then looked at learning rates, how fast did they learn this. The two groups (vertical and horizontal) learnt at a very simular rate. Next stage: wanted to test if horizontal and vertical components were learnt, remebered or used seperately or as integrated unit. Rotated maize to 45 degree from horizontal angle, giving fish option to swim either down and left or up and right. So the options the fish had was to coserve previously learnt vertical locations (if they had been taught to swim up and left then they could choose to swim up and right, or they could conserve previous horizontally learnt info and swim down and left.
- 182Resultoverwhelmingly chose to swim in the vertical direction, this persisted even when the food reward was removed. Clearly had seperated vertical horizontal and vertical components of space but they also had clear preference for vertical. But might be that they had only learnt vertical component and had completely ignored horizntal.
So went back and trained fish to swim up and left gain but this time just tested them purley horizontally. Not as stong results as before but still statistically significant amount chose to swim in learned horizontal direction. CONFUSING read holbrook and burt de perera 2011 - 183How do fish seperate the vertical and horizontal?Hydrostatic pressure - water flows downhill, get gradient of pressure. Its global, found all round the world so relatively stable. Pressure varies in linear fashion with depth. If you know your pressure then you know your depth. Fish cannot measure pressure directly though. But they do have a swim-bladder volume which they can use to determine their depth. If the fish can determine the speed it has moved (which it can) then it can also use the change in swim bladder volume to measure the rate of change and therefore its depth.
- 184Two types of swim bladdersPhysoclist swim bladder - dynamic organ, oxygen pumped in and absorbed from it. No connection to the oesophagus.
Physostome swim bladder - direct gas connection to the oesophagus which means it is very quick to fill up because animal can gulp water from surface.
Swim bladders used in beer to filter - 185Pressure sensitivity - how good is this pressure sensitive systemFish can detect acute changes in hydrostatic pressure changes. They are sensitive to additional changes in pressure after initial vertical movement. Its able to use muscls on side of swim bladder, it is able to get swim bladder in position where it can sense new pressure changes very quickly.
- 186How do fish represent space when they swim freely through their environment?Holbrook and burt de perera, animal behavour 2013.
Differences between training direction and test direction were very small. Fish usually swam following their training tregectory.
Information
- Description
- Biology Flashcards on zoology, created by Tara McShane on 07/05/2017.
- Created by
- Tara McShane
- Views
- 5
- Rating