Help shape GoConqr. What should we add next?

Mind map

Social Exchange and Equity Theory

charlotteaherrin Psychology A-Level English

Mind map on social exchange and equity theory: social exchange theory, equity theory, AO2 and cultural bias

Mind map: Social exchange and equity theory

Map content

Social Exchange and Equity Theory

  1. Social Exchange Theory

    • Social behaviour is view as a series of exchanges between individuals
    • Each person attempts to maximize their rewards and minimize their costs
    • The exchange part of this process is that when individuals receive rewards from others, they feel obliged to reciprocate
    • Rewards= exchanged resources that are pleasurable and gratifying- e.g. company, security, sexual favours
    • Costs= exchanges that result in a lost or punishment- e.g. physical or psychological abuse and loss of their opportunities
    • The rewards minus the costs equal the outcomes
    • Comparison levels- general model of social exchange theory -Thibaut and Kelley (1959) proposed a four-stage model of long term relationships ; They introduced two ‘reference levels: Comparison level and Comparison level for alternatives:
    • The comparison level is concerned with the past and the present; that is the comparison between the rewards and costs of the reference (current) relationship and what we have been used to in the past or believe is appropriate given the nature of the relationship. (If comparison is favourable we’ll be motivated to stay in the relationship). A person may also use the experience of others.
    • Comparison level for alternatives is concerned with the benefits of possible alternative relationships. We compared the outcomes of the reference relationship with other that we could be in (e.g. more positive outcomes offered by an alternative partner). If we feel we can do better in another relationship, we may finish our current one. A person may also consider what is available from their social network.
  2. Equity Theory

    • Equity theory (Walster et al 1978) offers an explanation of how social change works in real-life romantic relationships
    • It assumes that people strive to achieve fairness in their relationships and feel distressed if they perceive unfairness
    • Inequality in relationships is seen as having the potential to create dissatisfaction
    • People who contribute a great deal in a relationship and receive little in return would perceive inequality
    • Those who receive a great deal and give little in return would perceive equality
    • These types of relationships would be perceived as inequitable, resulting in the dissatisfaction of both partners
    • Equity doesn’t necessarily mean quality; rather it refers to balance and stability
    • Walster et al (1978) suggested four principles of equity theory:
      • 1)People try to maximise their rewards and minimise their negative experiences with any relationship
      • 2) The distribution of rewards is negotiated to ensure fairness. This may be achieved through trade-offs or compensations
      • 3) Unfair relationships produce dissatisfaction. The ‘loser’ feels the dissatisfaction more acutely; greater the degree of perceived unfairness, the greater the sense of dissatisfaction
      • 4) As long as the ‘loser’ feels there is a chance of restoring fairness and is motivated to save the relationship, he or she will endeavour to re-establish equity. Furthermore, the greater the degree of inequity that the loser perceives, the greater the effort at realignment
  3. AO2

    • Contrived methodologies and limited application- Many of the studies associated with social exchange theories have been characterised by rather contrived methodologies, which have little ecological validity. Ragsdale and Brandau- Brown (2007) reject the claim that equity is a key determinant of relationship satisfaction. They claim that this does not reflect the way that partners in long-term relationships behave with respect to each other. For example, Feeney et al (1994) found that equity theory failed to predict relationship satisfaction because it fails to take into account the considerable variance in the contexts of modern-day relations
    • Lack of consistent empirical support-Clark and Mills (1979) identified two different styles of couples; the ‘communal couple’ and the ‘exchange couple’. In the communal couple, concern and positive regard for the other motivates giving; only in the exchange couple is there the kind of ‘score-keeping’ that is predicted by exchange theory. People in communal relationships do have some concerns over equity, but they are more relaxed over what it comprises. They tend to think that in a relationship, rewards and costs eventually balance out and equity is achieved.
    • Gender differences- Prins et al (1993) found that among Dutch couples, inequality in a relationship had different consequences for males and females. Males who perceived inequity in their relationship did not express the desire to have an affair and nor did they report that they had done so. Women, however, were more likely to respond to perceived inequity in their relationships by considering an extra marital affair for just this reasons.
    • Other research (e.g. Kahn et al 1980) has found that men are more likely to focus on the norm of equity in relationships, i.e. what you get out of a relationship should be more or less equal to what you put in. Women on the other hand, were more likely to focus on the norm of equality (i.e. both partners should receive equal amounts of benefits, regardless of how much they put into the relationship).
  4. IDA- Cultural bias in economic theories of relationships

    • Work carried out in societies other than north America tends to give little support for equity theory. For example, Lujansky and Mikula (1983) found no equity effects on romantic relationships in Austria, while Gergen at al (1980) found that whereas American students preferred equity (i.e. a constant ratio of rewards to imputs), European students preferred equality. Moghaddam et al (1993) argued that the emphasis on exchange and equity is a reflection of the dominant values of North America, where these theories of social relationships were developed. They claim that these theories reflect the highly individualistic, capitalist and protestant work ethic in North America.

Information

Description
A-Level Psychology (Relationships ) Mind Map on Social Exchange and Equity Theory, created by charlotteaherrin on 19/11/2015.
Views
0
Rating

Feedback

What is it about?

What should we add next?