Help shape GoConqr. What should we add next?

Mind map

Week 17: Key Studies of Topic D

Millie Carless Psychology GCSE English

Map content

Week 17: Key Studies of Topic D

  1. Jones (1924) study of little peter

    • 2 Strengths
      • 1: Jones made detailed observations over a long period. why?: Lots of qualitative data to draw conclusions.
      • 2:  Jones made the people order the tolerance series. why?: Objective as she can't make is seem like he improved because of knowing and affecting the results.
    • 2 weaknesses
      • 1: Gaps between sessions were variable; sometimes observed twice in one day, sometimes not for 2 months. Why?: Time is an extraneous variable - he may have improved by himself over time rather than as a result of the therapy (no cause and effect)
      • 2: Jones used 2 different techniques (classical conditioning and SLT) as well as the people who made Peter confident. Why?: Can't see cause and effect - don't know which one made him better.
    • Aim
      • To investigate whether a phobia in a little boy could be deconiditiionedj and whether this would generalise to other objects.
    • Procedure
      • Peter was 2 years and 10 months when Jones began observing him. *Watched Peter playing with beads in his cot as an experimenter showed hum a white rat. Peter screamed and moved away, leaving the beads behind.
      • *Peters fear generalised to other objects with a similar texture. * Peter was also shown a rabbit and was more afraid of the rabbit then the rat, and so the rabbit was used for de-conditioning. *Peter had daily play sessions with 3 other children and the rabbit. Peter was sometimes observed alone. * He was put into a number of different situations over a long period of time. They started off with the rabbit being far away from him, and new situations were used to get Peter closer to the rabbit.He only moved on to the next situation when he showed no fear.
    • Findings
      • Peter sometimes got better, sometimes got worse and sometimes stayed the same. * Sometimes observed twice in a day and sometimes not so often. *When Peter came back after his real a big dog jumped at him and his carer, scaring them both and causing a set back. *From session 8 onwards, classical conditioning used to help Peter; given food at same time rabbits cage brought closer. *Other children acted as role models
      • *Peter was asked about what he did in the lab; didn't mention rabbit but later would say 'I like the rabbit.' *Lost fear of cotton, coat and feathers. * Reaction to rat and fur rug improved but didn't like them as much as the rabbit. * Accepted new animals; frogs, worms and mouse.
    • Conclusion
      • Both classical conditioning and SLT helped to decondition Peter. The decondition also reduced generalised fears and helped Peter to cope with new animals.
  2. Bennett-Levy and Marteaus (1984) study about animals and phobias.

    • 2 Strengths
      • 1:  Different participants answered the two questionnaires. Why?: It would be generalisable as lots of participants (results) were used; they are less likely to guess aim (demand characteristics)
      • 2: The participants did not need to see the animals that frightened them. Why?: Makes it more ethical as it's less distressing.
    • 2 weaknesses
      • 1: The participants were told that the animals were not harmful but many still thought that rats were. Why?: Instructions weren't effective.
      • 2:  The questionnaires only asked about 6 factors. ( how afraid they were, how near they could get to the animals, how ugly they were, how slimy they were, how speedy they were and how suddenly they moved. Why?: Other things make animals scary so the results may not be valid (show why people are afraid). Therefore, not generalisable.
    • Aim
      • To see whether we are more afraid of, or avoid, animals that: - Move quickly - Move suddenly  - Look very different from people
    • Procedure
      • * Used 2 questionnaires *Both asked about same 29 animals  *Participants told none of animals were dangerous  *Questionnaire 1: fear of animals and how close person would get t them - Fear Scale 1-3 (1= not afraid, 3 = very afraid) - Nearness scale 1-5 (1= enjoy picking it up, 5 = move further away than 2 meters)
      • *Questionnaire 2: how participants felt about each animal. Rated each species on three point scale (1=not, 2= quite, 3= very) for: - ugliness - slimness -how speedy they are -how suddenly they moved *30 men and 24 women answered Q1 *24 men and 25 women Q2 *Some participants also interviewed
    • Findings
      • People more afraid of some animals and less likely to get near them. Even though P's told that rats and jellyfish were harmless, still more likely to be afraid of them and didn't want to get close to them. When interviewed, P's described ugly animals as slimy, hairy and dirty, with antennae, eyes in odd places and a strange number of legs. Men & Women judged ugliness in similar ways. They didn't differ in how ugly, slimy, speedy or suddenly moving the thought animals were. However, women were less likely to approach many of the animals.
      • Overall people were: - Less likely to approach ugly, slimy, speedy or suddenly moving animals. - More afraid of ugly, slimy or suddenly moving animals. -Thought that speedy animals moved suddenly.
    • Conclusion
      • Features of ugliness, sliminess, seediness and sudden movement all  make animals more frightening. Ugliness is judged by how different an animal is from a human. Animals which cause phobias are ugly, slimy, speedy or sudden movers; supports idea that preparedness relates to animal's features and how they might have been threatening to survival.
  3. Heinrich et. al's (2005) study of cultural differences in phobias

    • Aim
      • To see if being brought up in different cultures affected social anxiety and fear if blushing.
    • Procedure
      • 909 Psychology students volunteered to take part; eight different countries and volunteered because interested in results. Korea = collectivistic  America = individualistic Students divided into two groups; individualistic cultures and collectivistic cultures. Given short description of social situation and asked how they would react. IF P's  would speak up or offer answer = low social anxiety answer.
      • IF P's did nothing = high anxiety social anxiety. P's also completed questionnaires social anxiety & blushing questionnaires. Social anxiety questionnaire  = individual fear of social situations and interaction with the people. Blushing questionnaire = fear of embarrassment because blushing is a bodily response to being embarrassed.
    • Findings
      • Collectivistic cultures response to descriptions = high social anxiety; answers rear avoided public interaction; more fearful of blushing and scored higher on social anxiety questionnaire compared to individualistic. Japan = highest, Germany = lowest
    • Conclusion
      • Collectivistic cultures show greater social anxiety and fear of blushing than individualistic cultures because collectivistic cultures have strict rules about acceptable behaviour. If social norm is broken, they are punish = more anxious. People in collectivistic cultures hold back through fear of letting group down if wrong. 
      • Different from individualistic cultures where there is a great emphasis on individuality. More important to stand out from crowd; shyness = burden.
    • Nature or Nurture?
      • NURTURE - learn social anxiety through culture we were brought up.
  4. Definitions

    • Social anxiety
      • Fear that someone has of social situations e.g. meeting new people
    • Customs
      • Longstanding practices of a particular group of people.
    • Traditions
      • Practices that have been handed down through generations.
    • Social norms
      • Behaviours or beliefs that are expected and accepted in a particular culture.
    • Individualistic cultures
      • Encourage the independence, personal achievement, competition and individuality.
    • Collectivistic cultures
      • Encourage group dependence, cooperation and group identity; rely on each other to achieve together. (Japan)

Information

Description
GCSE Psychology Mind Map on Week 17: Key Studies of Topic D, created by Millie Carless on 02/06/2017.
Created by
Millie Carless · Jun 2017
Updated
Apr 6, 2018
Views
2
Rating

Feedback

What is it about?

What should we add next?