Notes
Brendgen et al. (2005) - contemporary study - created from Mind Map
Content of the notes (1)
Page 1
Background
Aims
Procedure
Results and conclusions
Evaluation
Why study aggression? It is important to recognise signs of aggression early on so you can prevent people from being aggressive and dangerous to society in later life
Types of aggression
Brengden used the term "social aggression"because he studied covert and overt behaviour as well as non-verbal aggression
Previous research suggests aggression is 50% down to environment and 50% down to genes
MZ (monozygous) is where the twins have identical DNA. DZ (dizygous) twins have similar DNA but are not identical
Physical
Indirect
Relational
Non-verbal
aggression that causes harm to somebody or something eg. punching
Covert (not done openly) eg. spreading rumours
Covert or overt (more open) actions eg. threatening to withdraw a friendship
eg. pulling faces
1. How far is social aggression down to genes, shared or non-shared environment?
2. How far can the link between physical and social aggression in someone be explained by genes, shared or non-shared environment?
3. To what degree is physical aggression replaced by social aggression throughout development?
By the end of the study there were 234 pairs of twins in the study, all recruited from the Quebec newborn twin study and all being born between Nov.1995 and July 1998.
They studied: 44 male MZ , 50 female MZ, 41 male DZ, 32 female DZ, 67 mixed DZ
Study took place in Canada
Data gathered longitudinally at 5, 18, 30, 48 and 60 mths and then at 6 yrs
They measured aggressive behaviour by asking teachers and peers to rate the child's aggression
Children were given a booklet with all faces of their peers and asked to circle 4 who showed the behaviour that the statement described
Teachers used the Preschool Social Behaviour Scale and the Direct and Indirect Aggression Scales
The peer and teacher scores were then grouped to give the twin a score based on all measurements
Aim 1
Aim 2
Aim 3
Physical aggression is more likely to be caused by genetic factors and social by environmental factors
If one MZ twin is aggressive then the other probably will be
If one DZ twin is aggressive then the other might not be
A correlation was found linking physical and social aggression
Link best explained by genes rather than shared environment
Environmental factors probably change the way a child would express their physical aggression and this would explain why a child moves from physical to social
Physical aggression changes to social aggression throughout development but not the other way around
This could be explained by looking at how children recognise what is 'socially acceptable'
Strengths
Weaknesses
Large sample
Both genders
Behaviour measured by teachers and peers = less chance of bias
Potential to use findings to reduce aggression in later life
High ecological validity
High internal validity - peers and teachers agreed
Right to withdraw
No deception
Found conclusions to aims
All from same location (so similar culture)
Actual samples being compared are small (there were only 32 female DZ)
Not a lab experiment so hard to control variables
May not apply to children that aren't twins
Extraneaous variables couldn't always be monitored
Peers may not have understood what to do - could have circled random faces
Twins couldn't give their consent or be fully informed of what was going on
Age group is very specific

Information
- Description
- AS - Level Psychology (Biological) Note on Brendgen et al. (2005) - contemporary study - created from Mind Map, created by Alice Storr on 09/03/2016.
- Created by
- Alice Storr · Mar 2016
- Updated
- Jan 10, 2017
- Views
- 5
- History
-
- Created by Alice Storr · Mar 9, 2016
- Copied to Note by Alice Storr · Mar 9, 2016
- Rating
More on Child development, learning and aggression