Notes
UN's Secretary Generals
Content of the notes (7)
Page 1
TRYGVE LIE (NORWAY)
1946-1952; First SG
Served during Early CW to Globalisation of CW
Had to retire due to Soviet pressure
Korean War: Incurred the wrath of USSR when he helped gathered support for the defence of SK - KW never ended, it was a ceasefire with an unsatisfactory end.
Fired employees: He fired US employees in SG who he suspected to be Communists & allowed US to screen & dismiss Americans with Communist tendencies in SG; Incurred the wrath of USSR.
China: He supported China's right to a seat in UN which shows that he is against US; The USSR also boycotted UN to protest against China not getting a seat - China did not get a seat until 1971 & USSR boycotted UN due to this issue in 1950. He worked to end USSR boycott but it didn't work.
Supported the foundation of Israel: He passed military & diplomatic information to Israeli officials. UNTSO (1st peacekeeping mission) was greatly hindered due to entrenched interests of Arabs & hence could not end the 1948 AI war.
Iran crisis of 1946: USSR refused to give up occupied Iranian territory despite repeated reassurances so the alliance of the Kurdish & People's Azerbaijani forces engaged in fighting with Iranian forces - Negotiations by Iranian premier Ahmad Qavam & diplomatic pressure on USSR by US led to USSR withdrawal.
Kashmir: He tried to call for a ceasefire in 1947 - It ended in a ceasefire only because India and Pakistan fought themselves to exhaustion, nothing to do with UN ending it.
Berlin Blockade: He was criticised for failing to negotiate an end to BB & his proposals were not accepted.
Re-election veto: USSR vetoed his re-election as they saw it as illegal & refused to work with him.
He was known to be impartial who withstood pressure from both superpowers.
He had a reputation of being pragmatic & determined; pro-Israeli.
He annoyed both US & USSR; his actions were curbed and hampered by superpower interests.
Page 2
DAG HAMMARSKJOLD (SWEDEN)
1953 - 1961
Served during the Globalisation of the CW
He was unanimously appointed by GA & re-elected in 1957; he died in office.
Laos-Thailand border dispute 1959: He took initiative on his own in playing a major role in resolving this dispute; he did this without authorization although SC or GA didn't disapprove. The dispute was however resolved.
Intensive period of CW: He criticised the superpowers for disregarding UN role in peacekeeping; he believes in safeguarding international security.
Suez Crisis 1956: He tried to lessen tensions in this crisis; invented peacekeeping & the birth of UNEF - The conflict ended as USA put pressure on Britain, France & Israel and threatened embargo if they do not stop fighting.
Congo Crisis: He invoked Article 99 which authorised him to raise the issue of Congo to SC. However, he was accused of taking sides which USSR called for troika and Hammarskjold to step down - Congo was then left with an unsatisfactory government under Mobutu whom US supported since ONUC left.
Peking Formula: He negotiated for the release of 15 US pilots captured during KW whom were imprisoned by Beijing - Although his initiative was authorised by GA, he disassociated with it as he felt that it was too judgemental & also to assert his powers of intervention. His success greatly increased the readiness of the GA to rely on the SG as a trouble-shooter.
Setting up of the Secretariat: He began his term by establishing his own secretariat of 4000 administrators & set up regulations that defined their responsibilities.
He was known to be more diplomatic than Trygve Lie.
Inaction or stalemate either at the UN or outside of UN may be justification for the SG to act on his own.
He enhance the prestige of the office by using quiet diplomacy to resolve various conflicts.
He was one of the SGs with greatest potential had he not died so early.
Page 3
U THANT (BURMA)
1961 - 1971
Served during the emergence of 3rd World in UN; the first SG from a 3rd world country which gave him an advantage in dealing with colonialism issues.
He was reappointed unanimously by SC which affirmed the importance of SG's role.
He was accepted by both superpowers for 2 terms but retired after his 2nd term ended.
CMC: He facilitated negotiations between JFK & Krushchev in 1962, thereby narrowly averting the possibility of a global catastrophe; crisis ended when they agreed between themselves on the resolution of the conflict.
Dispute over Cyprus between Turks & Greeks 1964: In between the fightings, the SC decided unanimously on 4 March 1964 to authorize U Thant to establish a UN Peacekeeping Force in Cyprus (UNFICYP) to help maintain law & order and to aid in the return to normal conditions - Intercommunal talks began in June 1968; they were bogged down but U Thant proposed a formula for their reactivation. (talks continued even after he left the office)
UNIPOM (UN Indian-Pakistan Observation Mission) Sept 1965: Supervised ceasefire along the India-Pakistani border. After the troops withdrew, this was terminated - Limited observer mission; did not resolve the Kashmir conflict.
Withdrawal from Sinai in 1967: He was criticised by US & Israel for withdrawing troops from the Egyptian side which he argued he had no choice when Israel chose not to allow UNEF to remain & Nasser asked him to withdraw - Outbreak of Six-Day War; this was one of the several factors that triggered the war which had long term consequences.
Vietnam War: His relations with US deteriorated after he criticised US on Vietnam War; he attempted peace talks between US and vietnam but was rejected (bold move) - He adopted the 3-stage proposal to restore order to Vietnam in the Paris Talks in 1968 to intervene in Vietnam. However, he was completely ignored by US and his proposal was never brought up by SC or GA.
1971 Indo-Pakistani War over Bangladesh: U Thant offered his good offices to India & Pakistan & kept the SC informed under the terms of Article 99 & the Charter - When warfare broke out in December, SC appealed to all parties to spare the lives of innocent civilians. U Thant appointed a special representative to lend his good offices for the solution of humanitarian problems after the cease-fire of 18 Dec 1971.
Third World Issues:
1) He oversaw the entry of new Asian & African states into UN in 1960s.
2) He had to address increasing social and economic concerns of the 3rd World nations.
3) He established many of UN's development agencies like UNCTAD.
- The increasing domination of the 3rd World in the GA led to the bashing of the West in relation to social-economic issues.
He was more inclined towards neutralism.
It was critical for both East & West when he believed that their national purposes and actions threatened international security.
Both GA & SC assigned him to mediate extremely delicate situations, so he was known for his Good Offices role.
He wanted to ease the tensions between the superpowers while serving in the UN.
He played a quieter role than his predecessors and was less controversial due to the Great Powers; they delegated tasks to him instead of him exercising leadership.
He was largely ineffective when it came to dealing with the conflicts of interest to the superpowers (eg. he was unable to resolve the Vietnam conflict despite putting in so much effort)
He was questioned in his efficiency in dealing with the refugee crisis in the 1971 Bangladesh War.
He stepped on the toes of USSR when he criticised the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968 when he led 10 members in the SC to condemn USSR action but he was vetoed by USSR.
Page 4
KURT WALDHEIM (AUSTRIA)
1972 - 1981
Served during detente & renewal of the CW.
He continued 3rd World complaints in UN.
He was SG for 3 terms.
He generally kept a low-profile & was less inclined than his predecessors to offend major powers.
He tried to resolve several major international conflicts:
1971 India-Pakistani dispute: Little SG involvement; East Pakistan army surrendered to India.
Yom Kippur War 1973: He was unable to prevent the outbreak of war & could not enforce resolution 242 since US vetoed everytime. Superpowers put pressure on Arabs & Israelis to end the war then UN came in to mediate a ceasefire.
Vietnam's invasion of Cambodia in 1978: Cambodia was still under Hun Sen, supported by Vietnam; he could do very little.
Vietnam War: His efforts to mediate in the Vietnam war were unsuccessful due to the superpowers' refusal to cooperate; His critical comments about the US bombing on north Vietnam resulted in a public denouncement by Nixon.
Soviet invasion of Afghanistan: Efforts to deal with the Soviet invasion was futile due to CW tensions.
Iran-Iraq War: It was still ongoing when Mark ended his term; it could not transcend the Sunni-Shi-ite strife.
Iranian Hostage Crisis: Ayatollah refused to see SG; it ended when Iraq invaded Iran which diverted Ayatollah's attention. Algerian mediators secured the release of the hostages, not SG.
UN only mounted 3 new peacekeeping missions while he was SG:
Yom Kippur War - UNEF II & UNDOF; UNEF II was proposed by USSR and US which was a resolution whereas UNDOF was a product of Kissinger's negotiations with Syria. (not products of his initiative)
UNIFIL; It arose from US diplomacy & was ineffective in preventing the 1982 invasion of Lebanon by Israel.
Bangladesh: He inspected the United Nations Relief Operation in Bangladesh which was the largest relief operation ever undertaken under UN auspices.
Africa: In 1974, he visited a number of countries in the Sudano-Sahelian area of Africa, where UN undertook a major relief operation to assist the victims of a prolonged drought.
Waldheim Affair 1985: Nazi links came to light when he was running for Austrian presidency in 1985 - It has been asserted that both superpowers knew very well about his wartime past and the discrepancies in his autobiography before he was elected UN SG & there were rumours that KGB blackmailed him during his UN time.
He tarnished his reputation for being a Nazi which was not revealed until he finished his role as SG and sent Jews to concentrations camps during WWII.
He was the least distinguished of all UN SGs; he was publicly diplomatic but privately vain with a violent temper.
Page 5
JAVIER PEREZ DE CUELLAR (PERU)
1982 - 1991
Served during the end of CW & collapse of USSR.
He was the first Latin American SG; re-elected for 2nd term.
Falklands issue between Britain & Argentina: His efforts came to nothing but he was still commended for trying.
Namibia/Western Sahara dispute/Cyprus/Nicaragua: He enjoyed considerable success in resolving long standing problems in these areas. he interceded negotiations for the independence of Namibia.
Rainbow Warrior Incident 1985: An undercover operation conducted by the French military security service sank the Dutch-registered Greenpeace ship, Rainbow Warrior, and killed a Dutch photographer; this ship was planning to disrupt French Nuclear tests - In terms of reparations, France offered an official apology & acknowledgement of breach of international law. UN SG also awarded NZ 7 mil USD.
Disaster Relief in Ethiopia: There was more success in dealing with humanitarian matters.
Gulf War 1991: UN's intervention in the war was one of the greatest success in peacekeeping.
Conclusion of Iran-Iraq War: For the first time, US/USSR jointly sponsored SC resolution in Middle East: it showed the success of SG that he was determined by superpower cooperation.
Mediating role in El Salvador: This was possible also because the CW was starting to end and USSR had withdrawn funding to the 3rd World, so efforts in El Salvador was no longer hindered by CW rivalry.
He placed special emphasis on enhancing the independence, efficiency and morale of UN employees on depoliticising its subsidiary agencies to regain broad support for their work.
The end of CW marked the rise in prominence of SG's political role as seen in the number of successful mediations and resolutions to conflicts that Cuellar presided over.
He admitted that UN had serious defects and laboured with limited success to reform and revitalise the organisation.
Page 6
BOUTROS BOUTROS-GHALI (EGYPT)
1992 - 1996
The 1st post-CW SG & 1st Arab-African SG.
Served during the New World Order; after 1991 & the collapse of USSR.
He supported global free market policies which won him Western favour in terms of being re-elected.
Attempted to reform the UN; An Agenda for Peace 1992: This looks into the improvements for peace enforcements & peace building - He had the opinion that effective peacekeeping missions entailed the commitment of major powers. He berated UN members for failing to provide troops when needed and criticised SC for trying to 'micromanage' peacekeeping and peace enforcement operations.
Camp David accord involvement 1978: He was not SG in this time but was still involved; he was criticised by the Arabs as the architect of Camp David as "the academic engineer of Arab surrender".
Yugoslav wars from 1992; disintegration of Yugoslavia: The breakaway of Croatia, Slovenia, Bosnia from Yugoslavia that resulted in a series of wars in the Balkans - He managed to neogtiate for ceasefires in Slovenia and Croatia where the European community fails. A scaled down UNPROFOR was formed. US was opposed to Boutros-Ghali due to his reluctance on approving NATO bombing in Bosnia. However, this US opposition to the SG was supported by none of its allies.
Somalia 1992: He urged Bush to get involved and aid UN efforts - The Clinton administration was angry at him for the fiasco encountered in Somalia and the confusing mandates that resulted in the deaths of US troops and the humiliation of US. They succeeded in deluding the US public that it was Boutros-Ghali alone that led US soldiers to disaster in Somalia.
Declining of financing for UN by USA: US criticised UN for being bureaucratic - To put US' concerns to rest, Boutros-Ghali commissioned the Thornburgh Report by Richard Thornburgh which noted a high percentage of bureaucracy in UN and called for a cut in staff. Even after this report, he said that he would take steps to implement changes, however, he was still met with criticism from US; US criticised UN to be inept and bent on gaining power over US, therefore Clinton refused to support his re-election.
Rwandan Genocide: UNAMIR withdrew ultimately due to the lack of support from US whom refused to call it a genocide.
Angolan Civil War 1996: He was not able to muster support for UN support for resolution to Angolan civil war - There was a lack of interest from major powers especially US. The UN failed in Angola; it was given no more than a few hundred men to deal with de-arming 15000 soldiers = indifference of the international community to an orphan conflict.
Re-election issue 1996: He was the only SG not to be re-elected to 2nd term.
US ousting of Boutros-Ghali in a secret plan known as Orientation Orient Express: in 1996, 10 SC members sponsored a resolution backing Boutros-Ghali for a second 5-year term, but US vetoed this.
He was the most forceful leader since Hammarskjold which explains why he rubbed USA the wrong way and he challenged the dominance of US in UN.
He was criticised for being too activist and too passive.
Page 7
KOFI ANNAN (GHANA)
1997 - 2006
During the post-CW period riddled with orphan conflicts.
He was firmly supported by USA and was a consensus favourite in SC; unanimously re-elected in 2001 (2nd term).
Reform Plan: Renewing UN, restructuring & pruning UN's bureaucracy - He called for the overhauling of UN & particularly the SC, to make it more representative of UN's membership and to increase the organisation's effectiveness. However, he was not able to get member nations to agree to significant changes to UN's structure.
Weapons inspection non-compliance with Iraq 1998: He visited Iraq to resolve impasses between Iraq and SC over compliance with weapons inspection and other matters. This helped to avoid an outbreak of imminent hostilities for a brief moment. He was largely unsuccessful but he won the respect of SC and Saddam Hussein.
Shuttle Diplomacy in the Middle East 1998-2000: He apologised to Israel for UN's tone in the past - Israel warmed up to Annan and was willing to address the conflict with Palestinians. In 2000, he certified Israel's withdrawal from South Lebanon.
Rwandan Genocide: He was accused of blocking proactive measures and logistical support in protecting the Tutsis and failed to prevent the genocide. He apologised to the Rwandans for UN failure to aid them in their time of need.
Kosovo conflict 1999: He endorsed NATO's bombing of Yugoslavia but was criticised for working too closely with USA and ignoring SC's legitimacy; conflict ended.
East Timor conflict 1999: He negotiated with Indonesia for the May 1999 Agreement to hold a referendum to decide on East Timor's future. He was deeply involved in overseeing the process of holding of the referendum and helping the country transition to a state after its citizens voted for independence. He also tried to resolve post-referendum violence by pressuring Indonesia to restore stability to East Timor. He also oversaw peace building in East Timor.
Brahimi Report 2000: A reflection for peacekeeping and reform proposals: Annan appointed the Panel on United Nations Peace Operations to assess the shortcomings of the then existing system and to make specific and realistic recommendations for change.
Millennium Summit 2000: The largest gathering of world leaders in history to address challenges facing the world, peacekeeping, poverty, diseases and peace in the Middle East.
Nigeria 1998: He helped to ease the transition to civilian rule in Nigeria.
Information
- Description
- Junior Certificate History (SBQ - UN Secretary General) Note on UN's Secretary Generals, created by FOOCHOOLA3 . on 16/08/2016.
- Created by
- FOOCHOOLA3 . · Aug 2016
- Updated
- Feb 3, 2018
- Views
- 14
- Rating