Help shape GoConqr. What should we add next?

Mind map

LT5 - Factors Affecting EWT: Anxiety

Kiran Bacchus Psychology A level English

LT5 - Factors Affecting EWT: Anxiety

Map content

LT5 - Factors Affecting EWT: Anxiety

  1. AO1

    • Positive
      • High Physiological Arousal = More detailed memory
        • Evolutionary Argument?
          • Helps us avoid them in the future/adapt
      • Christianson and Hubinette
        • Procedures
          • 58 IRL Robbery Witnesses
            • High Anxious (Victims, Tellers) Vs Low Anxious (Bystanders, customers)
        • Findings
          • 75% Accurate, all Ps above average
            • All Conds had some anxiety
          • Most Anxious = Best Recall
        • Research review
          • Memory for -ve emotional events
            • far better than neutral events
              • atleast with central details
      • Yuille and Cutshall
        • Findings
          • Witnesses were highly accurate
            • Supports Evolutionary Theory
          • Very little variation
          • Highest Stress = Best recall
        • Procedures
          • 21 EWTs, 13 Study Ps
            • Interviewed 4 months after
              • Compared to original police interview
                • No. of specific details which matched when compared
          • Likert Scale (Stress Rating)
          • Ps asked for any emotional problems
            • Could bias results
          • 'Real life shooting'
    • Negative
      • Johnson and Scott
        • Weapon Focus Effect
          • Presence of weapon draws focus of witness
            • They ignore contextual details
        • Procedurees
          • Ps in Waiting Room
            • Loud argument overheard in a close by room
              • Grease/Pen Vs Bloody Knife
                • Field Exp - Natural Setting, IV Manipulation
        • Findings
          • Pen = 49% Accuracy of Witness Identification
            • Knife = 33%
          • Loftus supported
            • Eye movement tracking
              • Image of Q to pay at taco bell
                • One slide, person paid with cheque book
                  • Looked for 2.44 Secs
                  • Held Gun
                    • Looked for 3.71 Secs
                    • Gazed longer at gun, supports WFE
    • Why the contradiction?
      • Deffenbacher
        • Meta-analysis
          • 10 Studies - High arousal = Greater Accuracy
          • 11 Studies - High arousal - Lower accuracy
          • Inverted U
  2. AO3

    • Limitations
      • P: Anxiety not causing WFE
        • E1: JS measuring surprise > anxiety
          • E2: Pickel - Scissors, Handgun, Wallet, Chicken
            • E3: Worst EWT in high surprie conditions, even when threat was low
              • L: Low Internal Validity
      • Field Studies lack EV control
        • JS, PED, Sleep
      • P: Individual Differencecs
        • E1: Bothwell et al - Emotional Sensitivty, key EV
          • E2: Emotionally Stable Vs Neurotic
            • E3: Increase in stress = Increase/Decrease in recall accuracy
              • L: Lowers internal validity
    • Strengths
      • P: High Ecological Validity
        • E1: Real Life EWT examples (CH + YC)
          • E2: Real anxiety due to real crime
            • E3: Lab studies fail to recreate this
              • E4: Deffenbacher agrees, lab studies associated with poor EWT
                • L: Generalisable, experimenter bias

Images and files in the map

  • LT5 - Factors Affecting EWT: Anxiety
  • LT5 - Factors Affecting EWT: Anxiety

Information

Description
A level Psychology (NOT LISTED MATERIAL) Mind Map on LT5 - Factors Affecting EWT: Anxiety, created by Kiran Bacchus on 16/02/2022.
Created by
Kiran Bacchus
Views
1
Rating

More on Eyewitness Testimony

Feedback

What is it about?

What should we add next?