Mind map
improving the accuracy of EWT: cognitive interviews
Map content
improving the accuracy of EWT: cognitive interviews
the cognitive interview
- Fisher and Geiselman
- said interviews could be improved - using techniques which use psychological insight into how memory works
- four main techniques
- change the perspective
- do it from another persons view (victim/ suspect)
- why?
- disrupt the effects of expectations of set schema
- could just say what you expect to do/ see
- disrupt the effects of expectations of set schema
- why?
- do it from another persons view (victim/ suspect)
- change the order
- recall it in a different order than real life
- why?
- to stop reporting expectations and to stop from being untruthful - harder to keep track of a lie
- why?
- recall it in a different order than real life
- context reinstatement
- encouraged to return to the crime scene and imagine the environment and emotions
- why?
- context dependant forgetting
- why?
- encouraged to return to the crime scene and imagine the environment and emotions
- report everything
- say absolutely everything you remember
- why?
- every detail is important and may trigger other memories
- why?
- say absolutely everything you remember
- change the perspective
- four main techniques
- said interviews could be improved - using techniques which use psychological insight into how memory works
- Fisher and Geiselman
enhanced cognitive interviews
- Fisher
- developed the CI to focus on social dynamics of the interaction
- for example when to make eye contact and when not to
- key points
- reduce eyewitness anxiety, minimising distractions, getting the witness to speak slowly and open ended questions
- key points
- for example when to make eye contact and when not to
- developed the CI to focus on social dynamics of the interaction
- Fisher
evaluation
- cognitive interviews are time consuming
- more time needed to build up a good rapport, make the person feel comfortable
- need to be specially trained to do them
- more time needed to build up a good rapport, make the person feel comfortable
- some elements may be more valuable than others
- Milne and Bull
- single elements were effective
- most effective were report everything and context reinstatement
- if less elements used then more likely to be used by the police
- most effective were report everything and context reinstatement
- single elements were effective
- Milne and Bull
- support for the effectiveness of the ECI
- a meta analysis - Kohnken
- cognitive interviews are more accurate than normal interviews
- practical benefits - greater chance of catching and charging criminals
- cognitive interviews are more accurate than normal interviews
- a meta analysis - Kohnken
- cognitive interviews are time consuming
evaluation +
- variations of the CI are used
- police forces start to use their own methods
- CI creates an increase in inaccurate information
- even though the amount of correct info has increased so has incorrect info
- kohnken
- 81% increase in correct answers
- 61% increase in incorrect info
- 81% increase in correct answers
- kohnken
- even though the amount of correct info has increased so has incorrect info
- variations of the CI are used
Information
- Description
- AS - Level psychology (chapter 2 - memory ) Mind Map on improving the accuracy of EWT: cognitive interviews, created by Daisy U on 26/04/2016.
- Created by
- Daisy U
- Views
- 3
- Rating