Flashcards
Dissolution of relationships
Cards in this deck (31)
- 1What did Rollie and Duck propose?There are various explanations of why relationships breakdown or dissolve. Rollie and Duck proposed a five stage model for the dissolution of relationships.
- 2What are the first 3 phases?The first phase is the intrapsychic phase where there’s dissatisfaction in the relationship. The next phase is the dyadic phase where the dissatisfaction is discussed and there’s an opportunity to resolve. If this fails then they enter the social phase where the break up is made public and negotiation of children, finances and belongings occurs.
- 3What are the fourth and fifth phases?The fourth stage is the grave-dressing process where both partners begin to justify their actions and their dissatisfaction - both partners reflect on what happened, who was to blame, and decide on how they wish to view and communicate the reason for break up to other people. In the last phase – resurrection – both partners reflect on the relationship, recreate a sense of own social value and define what to get out of future relationships.
- 4Why are cultural differences an issue with this research?However this model doesn’t account for cultural differences in relationship as it can’t explain non-western cultures which have arranged marriage which can be more permanent and involve whole family in crises.
- 5How does this impact generalisability?This makes Rollie and Duck’s model ethnocentric making it lack population validity. The population validity is further lowered by its lack of generalisability to homosexual relationships who usually don’t involve decisions over children that heterosexual couples consider.
- 6Why is this model reductionist?Moreover, the model is reductionist as it doesn’t account for a range of relationships, such as casual affairs and friendships.
- 7How does it have face validity?However, it does have face validity and it has useful applications in counseling through which the phase at which a couple is at is assessed and strategies are made to help maintain and rescue the relationship.
- 8What did Lee propose?Lee proposed a five stage theory which is similar to Duck’s model.
- 9What are the first two phases?The first phase is dissatisfaction where an individual becomes dissatisfied with the relationship. The next phase is exposure where the dissatisfaction is revealed to ones’ partner.
- 10What are the last 3 stages?The third stage is negotiation where discussion occurs over the nature of the dissatisfaction which leads to the fourth stage – resolution – to resolve the dissatisfaction. If the dissatisfaction is not resolved – the relationship terminates (the fifth stage. Lee
- 11How did Lee create his theory?Lee created his theory after conducting a survey of 112 break-ups of non-marital romantic relationships, finding that negotiation and exposure stages were most distressing and emotionally exhausting. Individuals who missed out on stages, going straight to termination tended to be those with less intimate relationships. Those going through the stages in length and exhaustive fashion felt attracted to their former partner after termination and experienced greater feelings of loss and loneliness.
- 12What are the similar weaknesses between Lee and Duck's model?Lee’s theory too can be criticized for having the same weaknesses as Duck’s mode – is ethnocentric as they focus on western culture (individualistic) rather than non-westernized cultures (collectivistic) and so lacks population validity. They are both also reductionist because they don’t account for homosexual or other relationships- e.g. neither can explain abusive relationships whereby a partner won’t reveal their dissatisfaction and will instead simply walk away, thus avoiding the proposed stages of dissolution.
- 13What's a strength of Lee's research?However, strength of Lee’s research is that a substantial amount of information was gathered as the sample size was proportionally large which suggests the information is fairly reliable as a large sample size indicates less likelihood of results being due to chance.
- 14Why may the sample be unrepresentative?However the sample he used wasn’t very representative as it consisted of students from the same culture so it lacks generalisability and therefore population validity. Moreover, the theory was only carried out on students in pre-marital relationships and may not to dissolution of long-term relationships involving children and shared resources therefore this lowers generalisability to other relationships.
- 15How does it provide useful applications?However, both Lee and Duck’s model have practical applications in counseling.
- 16How are both models predictive?On the other hand both models are predictive rather than explanatory – they describe the process of dissolution but don’t provide explanations of why the process occurs.
- 17How do precipitating factors address this issue?Precipitating factors proposed by Duck (2007) addresses this issue and proposes risk factors that may lead to relationship breakdown.
- 18How is this a strength over the other 2 samples?This is strength over the other two models as it’s explanatory rather than predictive – it suggests why relationships break down rather than just laying out the stages of breakdown.
- 19How is lack of skills a precipitating factor?Lack of skills is a precipitating factors – this is when partners lack the social skills required to keep the other person interested which then leads others to believe they’re not interested and therefore the relationship breaks down.
- 20How is lack of support a precipitating factor?Another precipitating factor is lack of stimulation – according to social exchange theory; people look for rewards in their relationships, one of which is stimulation.
- 21What supporting evidence did Baxter (1994) find?There’s supporting evidence (Baxter 1994) that a lack of stimulation (e.g. boredom or a belief that the relationship wasn’t going anywhere) is often quoted when breaking off a relationship.
- 22How is maintenance difficulty a precipitating factors?The final precipitating factor is maintenance difficulties where there are some instances where partners can’t maintain close contact and this puts a strain on the relationship which then breaks down.
- 23How is a particular problem with long distance relationship? Give evidenceThese maintenance difficulties may arise particularly in long distance romantic relationships (LDRR) and long distance friendships (LDF) which are more common than we might think – Rofling (1995) found that 70% of students sampled had experienced at least one LDRR and that 90% had experienced a LDF.
- 24How are all these factors supported by extramarital affairs?All these precipitating factors are supported by extramarital affairs. A major reason why relationships break down is that one or both partners have an extramarital affair. Boekhout et al (1999) showed how such affairs might be a direct reaction to perceived lack of skill and/or stimulation possibly as a result of long distance relationships.
- 25What did Boekhout et al (1999) do?They asked undergraduates to rate various sexual and emotional reasons for men and women to be unfaithful in a committed relationship. Participants judged that sexual reasons for infidelity (e.g. sexual excitement, boredom) would be more likely to be used by men, whereas emotional reasons for infidelity (e.g. lack of attention, lack of commitment, emotional satisfaction) would be more likely used by women.
- 26What can be suggest about this?Clearly there are gender differences when it comes to dissolution of relationships that need to be considered as well.
- 27Why is cause and effect an issue?Moreover, there is an issue of establishing the direction of cause and effect with them. Do lack of stimulation/skill lead to extramarital affairs or do extramarital affairs lead to one of the partners being disengaged?
- 28How is the theory ethnocentric?It also doesn’t account for abusive relationships where one of the partners clearly lacks skills and there are maintenance difficulties so this theory too is ethnocentric as it’s based on the individualist view of western societies.
- 29How is there face validity in Lee and Duck's model?However precipitating factors, like Lee and Duck’s model, also have face validity making all three acceptable explanations for the dissolution of relationships.
- 30Why do we need to consider all 3 explanations?However, as each approach has its own strengths and weaknesses so perhaps we need to consider all three explanations to explain the risk factors (Duck 2007), events leading up to (Lee’s theory) and processes after (Duck’s model) the breakdown of relationship.
- 31Why is considering any one theory reductionist?Considering any one in isolation is reductionist and will at best give an incomplete explanation - all three together explain the dissolution of relationships holistically.
Information
- Description
- A-Level psychology A2 (Condensed essays) Flashcards on Dissolution of relationships, created by kiruthicka on 25/05/2015.
- Created by
- kiruthicka
- Views
- 0
- Rating
More on Relationship breakdown